Jacksonville’s 8 Safest Neighborhoods Ranked by Crime & Rent Prices 2025

Jacksonville’s safest neighborhoods of East Arlington, Deercreek, Greenland, Baymeadows, Windy Hill, Duclay, Arlington Hills, and Arlingwood stand out in 2025 for lower crime rates, solid livability, and renter-friendly pricing. With Jacksonville crime rate 2025 still above the national average, these areas offer peace of mind without forcing renters to break the bank.

To help you start your search, we’ve created a data‑driven guide considering crime data with Apartment List rent figures, school ratings, walkability, and streetlight density.

How We Ranked Jacksonville’s Safest Neighborhoods

We used a weighted, data-driven model to rank neighborhoods based on key safety and livability factors. Here’s how we weighted each factor:

• Violent crime rate: 36%
• Property crime rate: 24%
• Rent prices: 15%
• Public school quality: 10%
• Walk score: 10%
• Streetlight density: 5%
• Total: 100%

When looking at these figures, it’s important to note that higher scores mean safer neighborhoods based on our weighted data model.

Data Sources and Crime‑Rate Formula

Our crime metrics come from a combination of looking at FBI Uniform Crime Reporting Program (UCR) aggregates, CrimeGrade.org, NeighborhoodScout, and AreaVibes. Rent figures are based on Apartment List’s June 2025 average of $1,456 for an apartment in Jacksonville.

Jacksonville’s Crime Snapshot

• Violent crime: ~698 per 100,000 (~1 in 143)
• Property crime: ~2,970 per 100,000 (~1 in 35), placing Jacksonville’s overall crime rate 60% to 80% higher than the national average.

Safe Neighborhood Rent Snapshot

While rent prices in low-crime areas tend to be higher, many in Jacksonville still offer solid value compared to coastal Florida cities. Here’s how average rents compare in the city’s safest neighborhoods:

Most of Jacksonville’s safest neighborhoods actually fall at or below the citywide average rent, with only a couple exceeding it by a modest margin. This makes it possible to prioritize safety without paying a significant premium, especially in areas like Duclay, Arlington Hills, and Arlingwood, which offer strong value.

Trends That May Impact Safety Next Year

• East Arlington: Continued growth in nearby apartment developments may increase traffic and pedestrian activity, especially along Atlantic Boulevard and Monument Road. No new sidewalks or lighting upgrades were announced.
• Baymeadows: Ongoing commercial development near Southside Boulevard may affect traffic patterns and increase foot traffic. The Jacksonville Sheriff's Office has responded to occasional traffic safety concerns in the area.
• Windy Hill: Roadwork along Hogan Road and Gate Parkway may temporarily reduce visibility and walkability. Expect occasional lane closures through late 2025.
• Duclay: New mixed-use proposals near Blanding Boulevard could bring more retail and residential units, potentially raising density and impacting traffic safety in the long term.

How to Read Our Safety Scores

Each neighborhood below has been assigned a composite safety score out of 100, based on crime rates, rent data, schools, walkability, and lighting. Here's how to interpret the numbers:

• 85 to 100: Excellent
• 75 to 84: Very good
• 65 to 74: Moderate

Jacksonville’s Eight Safest Neighborhoods

Whether you're raising a family, moving for work, or just want peace of mind, these affordable Jacksonville neighborhoods rank highest for safety based on crime data, walkability, lighting, and community reputation. We also factored in rent affordability, nearby schools, and commuter access to help you find a secure spot that fits your lifestyle.

1) East Arlington

• Violent crime rate: 6.0 per 1,000
• Property crime rate: 15.0 per 1,000
• Average rent: $1,677
• Composite safety score: 85/100
• Top amenities: Suburban layout, access to beaches, larger homes
• Public school rating: Moderate
• Walk score: 8
• Streetlight coverage: Moderate
• Commute to Downtown: 15 minutes via Mathews Bridge
• Transit options: Jacksonville Transportation Authority (JTA) routes 10, 18, 202

East Arlington balances affordability and safety with spacious layouts and solid infrastructure, making it popular among roommates and families alike. The area’s location offers a short drive to both Downtown and the Beaches, plus access to everyday retail. Though not highly walkable, the neighborhood feels stable and moderately lit. It continues to attract renters seeking value without sacrificing comfort.

2) Deercreek

• Violent crime rate: 2.5 per 1,000
• Property crime rate: 10.0 per 1,000
• Average rent: $1,661
• Composite safety score: 86/100
• Top amenities: Gated homes, private roads, proximity to nature preserves
• Public school rating: Above average
• Walk score: 8
• Streetlight coverage: Moderate
• Commute to Downtown: 22 minutes via Interstate 95
• Transit options: First Coast Flyer Blue Line, Express Select St. Johns Line, and routes 23 and 27

Deercreek is a low-traffic, gated community with HOA oversight and a strong safety profile. Its upscale housing and controlled access make it a top choice for security-minded renters. Residents value the privacy and natural surroundings just outside Southside’s busier zones. While it lacks walkability, the area offers privacy, green space, and well-maintained roads. Most errands require a vehicle.

3) Greenland

• Violent crime rate: 3.2 per 1,000
• Property crime rate: 12.7 per 1,000
• Average rent: $1,439
• Composite safety score: 83/100
• Top amenities: Newer builds, parks, suburban privacy
• Public school rating: Above average
• Walk score: 8
• Streetlight coverage: Moderate
• Commute to Downtown: 20 minutes via Interstate 95
• Transit options: Express Select St. Johns Line; primarily car-reliant

Greenland is a newer suburban area known for its quiet streets, strong schools, and low crime. Families and professionals appreciate the calm atmosphere and distance from heavy traffic. While daily errands require a vehicle, the payoff is peace of mind and privacy. The housing stock is modern, and green space is abundant. Renters enjoy a calm environment with few safety concerns. However, most amenities require a short drive.

4) Baymeadows

• Violent crime rate: 5.0 per 1,000
• Property crime rate: 18.0 per 1,000
• Average rent: $1,442
• Composite safety score: 79/100
• Top amenities: Apartments, restaurants, business parks
• Public school rating: Average
• Walk score: 25
• Streetlight coverage: High
• Commute to Downtown: 18 minutes via Interstate 95
• Transit options: Express Select St. Johns Line and JTA routes 27, 28, and 50

Baymeadows blends rental convenience with commuter access, offering proximity to offices and dining. Renters benefit from short drives, major roads, and multiple transit lines. While crime rates are moderate, visibility is strong thanks to high lighting and retail activity. The area suits renters who value accessibility over quiet. Expect higher traffic, especially during rush hours.

5) Windy Hill

• Violent crime rate: 5.6 per 1,000
• Property crime rate: 16.5 per 1,000
• Average rent: $1,503
• Composite safety score: 82/100
• Top amenities: Retail plazas, modern rentals, highway access
• Public school rating: Moderate
• Walk score: 31
• Streetlight coverage: High
• Commute to Downtown: 18 minutes via Hart Bridge Expressway
• Transit options: JTA routes 8, 23 and 28

Windy Hill offers newer apartments, walkable retail, and fast highway connections. The area scores well for lighting and location, especially near shopping centers. Crime rates are modest, and infrastructure supports safe access to essentials. The neighborhood is best for renters who want convenience without the congestion of Downtown. The central location makes it popular among commuters.

6) Duclay

• Violent crime rate: 6.4 per 1,000
• Property crime rate: 19.8 per 1,000
• Average rent: $1,282
• Composite safety score: 75/100
• Top amenities: Parks, schools, affordable homes
• Public school rating: Average
• Walk score: 23
• Streetlight coverage: Moderate
• Commute to Downtown: 23 minutes via Blanding Boulevard
• Transit options: First Coast Flyer Orange Line and JTA Route 31

Duclay is an affordable, family-friendly option with modest crime rates and solid infrastructure. Homes range from older rentals to single-family lots near schools and parks. Renters appreciate the space, access to public amenities, and relatively quiet atmosphere. Safety could be improved with better lighting and pedestrian upgrades.

7) Arlington Hills

• Violent crime rate: 6.9 per 1,000
• Property crime rate: 21.0 per 1,000
• Average rent: $1,218
• Composite safety score: 74/100
• Top amenities: Affordable homes, mature trees, local retail
• Public school rating: Below average
• Walk score: 26
• Streetlight coverage: Moderate
• Commute to Downtown: 17 minutes via Mathews Bridge
• Transit options: JTA Route 19

Arlington Hills is one of the most budget-friendly neighborhoods with decent safety scores. Though schools lag behind, the area is stable, quiet, and filled with mature landscaping. Renters enjoy access to local shopping and fast commutes via Mathews Bridge. Infrastructure is aging but still functional for day-to-day needs. The area suits those prioritizing savings and basic access. Streetlight coverage and sidewalks are spotty but improving.

8) Arlingwood

• Violent crime rate: 7.1 per 1,000
• Property crime rate: 21.5 per 1,000
• Average rent: $1,186
• Composite safety score: 73/100
• Top amenities: Starter homes, highway access, green space
• Public school rating: Below average
• Walk score: 32
• Streetlight coverage: Moderate
• Commute to Downtown: 13 minutes via Mathews Bridge
• Transit options: First Coast Flyer Red Line and JTA routes 10, 15, 19, and 23

Arlingwood is a low-cost neighborhood with a growing appeal among renters looking for quick city access. While crime is slightly higher, many blocks are quiet and family-oriented. Renters value the easy layout, greenery, and basic affordability. It’s a smart choice for those prioritizing price and practicality.

Balancing Safety with Affordability

Your ideal neighborhood doesn’t require a premium if approached strategically—even safe areas can be affordable if you know these tips:

• Search in late fall and winter for a better chance of move-in deals.
• Negotiate longer leases to reduce the monthly cost.
• Share rent to make higher-cost areas viable.
• Use Apartment List filters to zero in on well-lit buildings and gated access.

Areas like Greenland offer lower-than-average rents without sacrificing peace of mind. If you’re willing to trade a shorter commute or flashy amenities for better safety scores, these neighborhoods can offer real value and long-term livability.

Apartment Features That Enhance Personal Security

Safety also depends on your apartment:

• Controlled access buildings
• Well-lit parking or garages
• Smart locks, package lockers, and secure entry systems

While neighborhood safety is key, your apartment’s features can make a big difference too. Look for units with smart locks, well-lit entrances, gated access, and on-site security measures. Prioritizing these features gives you more control over your daily peace of mind—no matter which part of Jacksonville you call home.

Tools for Monitoring Crime in Your Desired Neighborhood

Before signing a lease, it’s smart to research neighborhood crime trends. Fortunately, several free tools and websites make it easy to check safety ratings, recent incidents, and long-term crime patterns in any Jacksonville ZIP code.

• Jacksonville Police Department crime maps
• CrimeGrade.org and NeighborhoodScout neighborhood indexes
• Google Alerts for “[neighborhood] Jacksonville crime”
• Citizen App alerts and UCR data feeds

Using crime-tracking tools helps you make informed decisions and avoid surprises. When paired with rent data and local insights, they give you a clearer picture of where to live safely and confidently.

Find a Safe Apartment in Jacksonville, FL

Safe Jacksonville neighborhoods, including Deerwood and East Arlington, offer the ideal mix of comfort, security, and convenience. Whether you’re a first-time renter, relocating with family, or just want a quiet home base, these areas deliver safety without sky-high rent.

Take Apartment List’s personalized quiz to discover listings that match your budget, location preferences, and safety priorities. It only takes a few minutes and helps you skip the guesswork. With us, you’ll spend five minutes and save 50 hours searching.

Frequently Asked Questions About Jacksonville’s Safest Neighborhoods

What is the safest neighborhood in Jacksonville with rent under $1,700?

Windy Hill is one of the safest neighborhoods under $1,700, with a strong safety score (82/100), high walkability, and excellent lighting. Greenland is another standout, combining low crime, newer developments, and family-friendly parks, all while staying just below the city average rent.

Which safe Jacksonville neighborhood offers the fastest commute to Downtown?

East Arlington offers one of the quickest commutes to Downtown, around 15 minutes via Mathews Bridge, while maintaining a solid safety profile and suburban feel. It’s popular with families and roommates seeking both value and access.

Are crime rates going up or down in these neighborhoods?

Jacksonville’s overall crime rate has decreased in the past year, and areas like Deercreek, East Arlington, and Greenland continue to report low violent crime and strong infrastructure support.

Which safe neighborhoods have gated communities or controlled access?

Deercreek is the top gated community on the list, featuring HOA oversight and private roads. Greenland also has some newer gated rental properties and subdivisions with monitored access.

How reliable is public transit or rideshare in safer areas of Jacksonville?

Transit is more accessible in Windy Hill, Baymeadows, and East Arlington—all served by JTA routes with proximity to key corridors. More suburban areas like Arlington Hills and Greenland are better suited to car owners or rideshare users.

Which safe neighborhoods are best for families with kids?

Greenland, East Arlington, and Duclay are top picks for families. They offer parks, above-average school access, and low to moderate crime with affordable rental options.

What’s the safest neighborhood near the beach in Jacksonville?

While not directly beachfront, East Arlington is the closest safe neighborhood with quick access to Jacksonville Beach and offers suburban amenities with solid crime ratings.

Are there quiet, low-crime neighborhoods close to nature in Jacksonville?

Yes, Deercreek and Greenland both offer peaceful, low-crime environments with proximity to green space, wooded areas, and hiking trails.