72 Apartments for rent in Bay Shore, NY

Read Guide >
Last updated December 13 at 2:09pm UTC
1175 Cassel Ave
West Islip
Bay Shore, NY
Updated December 12 at 6:04pm UTC
1 Bedroom
$1,675
Results within 1 miles of Bay Shore, NY
46 Islip Ave
Islip
Islip, NY
Updated December 13 at 11:53am UTC
1 Bedroom
$1,575
12 Shore Ln
Bay Shore
West Bay Shore, NY
Updated November 30 at 11:17am UTC
2 Bedrooms
$1,875
249 W 4th St
West Islip
West Islip, NY
Updated December 13 at 11:41am UTC
3 Bedrooms
$2,400
97 Greenwood Rd
Bay Shore
West Bay Shore, NY
Updated December 13 at 1:24am UTC
3 Bedrooms
$2,400
16 Willow Ave
Islip
Islip, NY
Updated November 17 at 9:51am UTC
Studio
$1,995
5B Hemlock Dr
North Bay Shore
West Bay Shore, NY
Updated November 30 at 11:18am UTC
1 Bedroom
$1,500
52 Nikia
Islip
Islip, NY
Updated December 13 at 11:42am UTC
2 Bedrooms
$2,050
3 Aztec
Bay Shore
West Bay Shore, NY
Updated September 14 at 11:57pm UTC
3 Bedrooms
$2,500
16 Willow Ave
Islip
Islip, NY
Updated December 13 at 11:42am UTC
1 Bedroom
$2,075
5 Yorkshire Dr
Wheatley Heights
Wyandanch, NY
Updated November 11 at 1:59am UTC
4 Bedrooms
$3,200
1745 N Gardiner Dr
North Bay Shore
West Bay Shore, NY
Updated December 12 at 5:51pm UTC
2 Bedrooms
$1,795
Results within 5 miles of Bay Shore, NY
16 Central Ave
North Babylon
North Babylon, NY
Updated December 10 at 10:02am UTC
3 Bedrooms
$2,300
114 N 21st St
Wyandanch
Wyandanch, NY
Updated October 18 at 1:47am UTC
3 Bedrooms
$2,000
463 Main St
Islip
Islip, NY
Updated November 5 at 9:03am UTC
2 Bedrooms
$2,485
59 Connecticut Ave
North Bay Shore
West Bay Shore, NY
Updated November 28 at 3:33am UTC
2 Bedrooms
$2,300
243 Helm Ln
West Bay Shore
West Bay Shore, NY
Updated December 7 at 1:31am UTC
3 Bedrooms
$3,500
169 Gibson
Brentwood
Brentwood, NY
Updated November 21 at 9:58am UTC
5 Bedrooms
$2,600
Apartment List detective logo

Keep Looking!

Try removing some filters or broadening your
search area to see more results.

Apartment List detective logo

Zoom in to see more.

Trying to get a feel for the larger area? No problem.
When you're ready, zoom in again to see pins and listings.

Apartment List sad heart

Something went wrong.

Please try your search again or reload the page.

City Guide
Bay Shore
How To Move There

The nice thing about moving to a place like Bay Shore, which is located in Long Island, is that leasing a rental property is far less grueling than it is in a place like Manhattan. Many, if not all, landlords will still require a credit check and security deposit, but few subject you to the painful, never-ending screening process that New York City’s inner-boroughs do. Plus, life is just more affordable in this gorgeous, coastal town. One bedroom apartments that, in the City, could be astronomical can be nabbed for much less than average in Bay Shore. Rental houses are also a deal, with many two and three bedroom properties available for reasonable prices as well and luxury condominiums (which are abundant in this post-renovation city) can be found in the same price range. All of this means that living within commuting distance of Bay Shore’s downtown, and marina is not only affordable: it’s downright pleasant.

Another trump card Bay Shore holds over the City is how easy its streets make transportation. Gone are the taxi-clogged avenues and flagrant-yet-so-important jaywalkers. Instead, you get to stroll down tree-lined neighborhoods with enough space to parallel park, play catch, and that have local, reliable bus service. Bay Shore is also a major stop on the Long Island Rail Road and a great relaxation point between Manhattan and Montauk. The train also gives riders access to the historic and seafaring Fire Island, a popular summer destination for many New Yorkers.

When thinking about where to live in Bay Shore, it’s important to take the varying neighborhoods into account. Bay Wood perfectly captures that quintessential mid-twentieth century suburbs feeling: quaint, and a real sense of community. The city’s Town Center, located south of Bay Wood, is definitely a little more urban, but offers residents access to the shores and coastal spots, which are very walkable and affordable. However, if you’re Pine Aire is adundant with large single-family homes are abundant. Really, number of choices you get in Bay Shore is fantastic, and whether you’re renting an apartment, a townhouse, or one of the city’s newer, luxury properties, you can rest assured that life in its sandy city limits will be brimming with ocean breezes and a little bit of true New York heritage.