Last updated September 26 at 4:38 AM

220 Apartments for rent in Shirley, NY

Any price
Beds
Baths
Sort by Last updated
Sort by Last updated
Budget
Beds
Any price
Beds
Baths
Sort by Last updated
Sort by Last updated
Budget
Beds
Check out 220 verified apartments for rent in Shirley, NY. Some apartments for rent in Shirley might offer rent specials. Look out for the
rent special icon!
542 Puritan Drive Photo Gallery 1
1 of 9
1 Bedroom
$1,950
900 sqft
owner requires approved application before scheduling showing-must have copy of full credit report, and proof of resources to pay rent, and previous landlord reference if possible. No smoking (inside or outside) . Tenant responsible for brokers fee. No pets. Tenant has own electric meter. Beautiful legal accessory apartment on quiet street close to LIE.
Read More...
Get the best commute
Get matched with your optimal commute
Let's go
101 Trafalgar Drive Photo Gallery 1
1 of 9
2 Bedrooms
$2,800
1300 sqft
Beachy 2 Bedroom - This beautiful 2-bedroom beach house is a short walk to the beach! House is available fully furnished or Unfurnished. Features include a large eat in kitchen, spacious living room with fireplace, fenced yard with seating area, and so much more! Requirements: Income of 85K per year or better, 4 person max occupancy, no smoking, credit of 660 or better, pet friendly with approval ( 2 pets max, no aggressive breeds ). Call Today! No Cats Allowed (RLNE7640332)
Read More...
Results within 1 mile of Shirley
The Reserve at the Boulevard Photo Gallery 1
1 of 19
1 Bedroom
$3,112
1084 sqft
2 Bedrooms
$3,123
1310 sqft
1-2 bedroom apartments with lush organic aesthetic. In-unit laundry and patio or balcony vistas. Maintenance on call 24/7. Parking, gym and pool available on site. Pets welcome.
Read More...
42 Carlton Avenue Photo Gallery 1
1 of 11
1 Bedroom
$1,900
Beautiful Brand New 1 bedroom apartment full bathroom Eik and living room - open concept - walk in closet. Private entrance-owner requests proof of resources to pay rent and copy of full credit report with applications.
Read More...
Shirley
| Learn more about Shirley
City Guide
264 Elm Rd Photo Gallery 1
1 of 19
2 Bedrooms
$2,600
3 Bedrooms
Ask
3 Bedroom, 1 Bathroom Entire House Available Now! - This whole house rental in Mastic Beach features 3 bedrooms and 1 full bathroom. This home has a great size front and backyard! Private drive way parking that fits 3 cars! Also included is access to the shed. Stainless Steel Stove, Fridge are all included in rental. Tenant is responsible for all utilities along with landscaping. 1st Month Rent, 1 Month Security Deposit, 1 Month Broker Fee Due at Lease Signing. *Pet Fees May Apply (RLNE7541590)
Read More...
Results within 5 miles of Shirley
Rosemont Brookhaven Photo Gallery 1
1 of 13
Verified
26 Units Available
1 Bedroom
$2,460
812 sqft
2 Bedrooms
$2,955
1119 sqft
3 Bedrooms
$3,235
1271 sqft
Community has a tennis court, gym, car wash area, and games room. Units are recently renovated with granite counters and in-unit laundry. Extra storage. Quiet setting near Sills Road shopping. Access to Sunrise Hwy and I-495.
Read More...
79 S Howells Point Road Photo Gallery 1
1 of 34
3 Bedrooms
$3,800
1778 sqft
2801 Billy Court Photo Gallery 1
1 of 8
Studio
$1,800
1 Bedroom
Ask
Spacious Ground Level Studio Apartment, Private Separate Entrance & Great Location Close to LIE & Route 112, Move Right Into This Beautiful Clean & Fresh Rental That Includes, All Utilities, Washer & Dryer, Cac & Heat, Street Parking Available, Cable Wifi Allowed by tenant, available September 15 https://secure2.ntnonline.com/securelease/default.cfm?propcode=CR255&unit=9618
Read More...
14 Country Club Road Photo Gallery 1
1 of 12
2 Bedrooms
$3,300
Charming Ranch nestled in the Heart of Bellport Village. 2 Bedroom, 1.5 Bath with bright and airy Eat-in-Kitchen with views of Park-like gardens. Freshly painted & central air. This one is too charming to last!!
Read More...
136 Crystal Beach Boulevard Photo Gallery 1
1 of 26
5 Bedrooms
$18,000
2900 sqft
This expansive Waterfront Home is Located in Crystal Beach Waterfront Community! Spend the summer at this Hamptons Fringe rental. Set at the end of a quet street on 1/2 acre of waterfront views of the River and Bay. Plenty of Outdoor Entertaining Space with an In-Ground Pool, decks, firepit, private dock, access to a private beach for amazing sunsets, long beach days and water sports. This expansive home offers 5 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, Large Walk Out Lower Level. and 2nd Floor Family Room. Master En Suite with Walls of Windows and balcony with overviewing incrediable waterviews. The gourmet Kitchen and Formal Living Room also provides full time waterfront views. Less than 1.5 hour from NYC.
Read More...
3 Ord Court Photo Gallery 1
1 of 5
1 Unit Available
1 Bedroom
$1,900
Large and spacious 1 bedroom 1 full bath apartment that includes all utilities.
8 Bay Road Photo Gallery 1
1 of 36
3 Bedrooms
$6,500
1538 sqft
BAY FRONT HOME. Magnificent home on a dead end street provides Bay access right from your backyard. This three bedroom and two full bath home has access to view the Bay from every level. Master bedroom has a private deck and view of the Bay with two more bedrooms and a full bath. Main floor is a generous Foyer, living room with high celings, formal dinng room and a gorgeous kitchen with views of the Bay. Lower level is a den with a wood burning fireplace, full bathroom, and access to the patio. Patio has a BBQ, sink and refrigerator to enjoy an outdoor meal. The backyard has open views and access to the Bay. This home allows access to the Private Beach, playground, patio, and boat launch owned and operated by the Bellport Beach Property Owners Association.
Read More...
89 Seymour Lane Photo Gallery 1
1 of 16
3 Bedrooms
$2,850
1224 sqft
3 Bed, 1 Bath House. Includes Cable and Landscaping. Full House, Year to 2 Year Rental. Rent includes access to security system. A/C is included.
Read More...
3 Valley Forge Court Photo Gallery 1
1 of 7
3 Bedrooms
$2,500
3 bed, 1.5 bath bath townhouse style unit in Strathmore Ridge
655 Bayview Avenue Photo Gallery 1
1 of 6
3 Bedrooms
$2,966
Beautiful 3 bedroom whole house rental in the heart of Bellport! Fully redone in last 5 years both inside and out. Tenant responsible for 1 month broker fee, security deposit along with first months rent at time of lease signing. All potential applicants mandated to undergo NTN screening as well as obtain renters insurance prior to lease signing. Voucher Programs Welcome!
Read More...
188 Edinburgh Drive Photo Gallery 1
1 of 15
2 Bedrooms
$3,800
1135 sqft
Don't Miss Out On This Gorgeous Newly Renovated 1135sq. ft. Huntington Model. Largest Model In Leisure Knoll, an Active 55+ Adult Community. Ready To Move Right In! Just Renovated Eat In Kitchen W/New Granite Counter Tops, New Range, and a Pantry. Master Bedroom Suite W/Newly Renovated Full Bath and a Walk-In-Closet. Whole House Freshly Painted. Renovated Guest Bath, Newer Carpet And Linoleum, Private Yard, Central Air. Laundry Area. 1 Car Garage with Private Driveway, Vacation At Home, and Enjoy Making New Friends with All the Community has to Offer - Club House, Pool, Tennis, Pickle Ball, Clubs And Crafts!
Read More...
177 Tarpon Avenue Photo Gallery 1
1 of 10
3 Bedrooms
$4,500
2600 sqft
Month to Month furnished House rental. Two sliding doors leading to rear yard that offers build in pool, waterfall cabana bar with bathroom facilities. Fireplace in family room with washer and dryer off of kitchen. Tile floors throughout and much more....
Read More...
Results within 10 miles of Shirley
The Point at Pine Ridge Photo Gallery 1
1 of 31
1 Bedroom
$2,543
839 sqft
2 Bedrooms
$2,865
1164 sqft
Rocky Point State Pine Preserve and three shopping malls surround one- and two-bedroom luxury apartment units. Private balconies and access to tennis court and golf course.
Read More...
New Village at Patchogue Photo Gallery 1
1 of 35
1 Bedroom
$2,971
746 sqft
2 Bedrooms
$3,363
1105 sqft
3 Bedrooms
Ask
Modern layouts featuring community amenities like green roofs, safe parking, swimming pool, sundeck and fully equipped fitness center. Conveniently located near art, music, shopping and restaurant venues.
Read More...
30 Club Lane Photo Gallery 1
1 of 12
4 Bedrooms
$28,000
2800 sqft
9 Tower Hill Road Photo Gallery 1
1 of 23
5 Bedrooms
$18,000
4400 sqft
Rare opportunity to vacation in a turn of the century stunner with picturesque Shoreham Village location, close to beach & all amenities. Fully furnished, completely updated inside and out in 2020 with exquisite details and 3 levels of living. 3 story entry sets the stage into the ground level space which offers Bedroom/Office w sep ext entry, 2 full baths, laundry and rec room. Stunning glass & stone wrapped staircase leads to Den w soaring ceiling & fp, sun room w French door to deck. FDR w fireplace is open to gourmet kitchen w breakfast bar & dining area. 3 Bedrooms Suites with luxurious bathrooms & walk-in closets, additional bedroom (5). 2 suites have fireplaces. Village amenities include clubhouse, tennis, playground, field, and private beach.
Read More...
807 Dune Road Photo Gallery 1
1 of 19
6 Bedrooms
$70,000
3000 sqft
Dramatic Ocean front, views and beautiful sunsets over Moriches Bay. 6 Bedroom, 5 Bath home with open floor plan, bay and ocean decks, hot tub.
Read More...
30 Carman Street Photo Gallery 1
1 of 6
1 Bedroom
$2,000
18 Remsen Lane Photo Gallery 1
1 of 36
4 Bedrooms
$75,000
18 Remsen Lane has everything you need for the ideal getaway: Tennis, Pickleball, Pool and more: four bedrooms (with an extra bedroom and room for ten), newly resurfaced court,, pathway to a natural pond, game room, media room with 85-inch screen, eat-in cook's kitchen, light-filled open living areas great for entertaining and relaxing. Completely renovated with genius features including a remote-controlled screened-in porch, and retracting glass walls for fresh air and sunshine. Multiple living spaces indoors and out, kitchen with Brazilian macauba island with generous seating. Primary suite has private terrace, vaulted ceiling and luxurious marble bath with steam shower and soaking tub. Additional bedrooms and baths are bright and stylish. In the finished lower level: media room, full bath, gym, and lounge and bonus office space. All on one of the prettiest lanes in Remsenburg, 4 miles from Westhampton Beach's fabulous new Main St. 70 miles from NYC. Less Traffic, more fun.
Read More...
Find More Rentals in Nearby
Find More Rentals Near

Find an apartment for rent in Shirley, NY


Searching for an apartment for rent in Shirley, NY? Look no further! Apartment List will help you find a perfect apartment near you. There are 220 available rental units listed on Apartment List in Shirley. Click on listings to see photos, floorplans, amenities, prices and availability, and much more!

Tired of browsing? Take our personalized quiz. You’ll answer a couple of simple questions and we’ll put together a list of Shirley apartments that are best for you. We’ll also factor in your commute, budget, and preferred amenities. Looking for a pet-friendly rental, or an apartment with in-unit washer and dryer? No problem, we’ll provide you with apartments that match that criteria.

You can trust Apartment List to help you find your next Shirley, NY apartment rental! After all, everyone deserves a home they love.

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How much is rent in Shirley?

Apartment Rentals in Shirley start at $1,950/month.

How can I find a pet-friendly apartment in Shirley?

You can use the pet-friendly filter to find apartments that allow pets.

How can I tour apartments during the COVID-19 pandemic?

While some Shirley properties may not allow visitors at this time, most are open for business by phone or email. Please reach out to them directly for virtual touring options. Additionally, some properties may offer video and 3D tours, which can be found on the listing details page.

How much should I pay for rent in Shirley?

The answer to this question depends on your household income and a couple of other factors. You can use our Rent Calculator to figure out how much you should spend on rent in Shirley.

How can I find off-campus housing in Shirley?

You can use the off-campus housing filters to find apartments near colleges located in or around Shirley. Some of the colleges and universities in the area include Albertus Magnus College, Southern Connecticut State University, Yale University, University of New Haven, and Housatonic Community College.