of neighborhoods selected. We’ll search anywhere in .
Start your Shirley apartment search!
Select how many bedrooms you want.
What are you looking to pay?
Where are you looking to move?
Please enter a location.
Where do you want to live?
In specific areas
Anywhere in
What areas would you like to look at?
out of areas selected.
Where do you work or go to school?
We'll show you how far the commute is
to the places you go to the most.
Please enter a location or skip.
I want to live within
How do you get there?
I drive (without traffic)
I drive (in traffic)
I ride public transit
I bike
What do you prefer?
On-site laundry
In-unit laundry
Washer/dryer connections
What about parking?
What other features do you want?
Hardwood Floors
Air Conditioning
What pets do you have?
I care most about
Getting all my features
Staying in the location I want
Having the cheapest price
Don’t worry, this won’t remove any matches
About when would you like to move in?
I’m just looking
I want to move, but I’m not in a hurry
I need to move, but can be a little flexible
I’ve gotta move!
What lease length are you looking to sign?
Are you signing a lease with anyone else?
A cosigner
Roommates, partner, etc.
Me, myself, and I
What's your monthly household income, before taxes?
Be sure to include the total income from all adults.
(We use this to save you time & help you find rents you will qualify for.)
Great! Your income qualifies you for the rent you chose.
So you know, apartments typically require your monthly income to be 2-3x the rent. Exact income requirements may vary, so always double-check with the apartment.
Apartments require 2-3x the rent in monthly income
Your monthly income only qualifies for a max rent of . Do you want to change your max rent?
Yes. Set my max rent to
No, I'll stick with
Did you know apartments require 2-3x the rent in monthly income?
Depending on your exact income you may not qualify for all apartments up to $500.
Have you been evicted?
I've never been evicted
I've been evicted
How did you hear about Apartment List?
Please select all that apply.
TV / Streaming Video
Radio / Streaming Audio
Postcard / Snail Mail
Friend or Family
Renters love us!
We’re rated 4.5 out of 5 because renters have so much success finding places they love.
Oops! Please enter an email.
Looks like you've been here before. Welcome back.
Please log in to use this email.
Invalid email or password.
We've sent a password reset email with instructions to
You can close this window
Make your results better
Personalize your results by telling us what you think of your first three matches.

83 Apartments for rent in Shirley, NY

Read Guide >
Last updated January 22 at 3:42pm UTC
398 Wellwood Dr
Shirley, NY
Updated January 11 at 10:52am UTC
3 Bedrooms
92 Manor Dr
Shirley, NY
Updated January 3 at 11:24am UTC
3 Bedrooms
38 Midland Ave
Mastic, NY
Updated January 3 at 11:23am UTC
3 Bedrooms
Results within 1 miles of Shirley, NY
60 Carlton Ave
Mastic, NY
Updated January 3 at 11:21am UTC
3 Bedrooms
155 Maywood Dr
Mastic Beach
Mastic Beach, NY
Updated January 18 at 1:40am UTC
3 Bedrooms
222 Madison St
Mastic, NY
Updated January 22 at 9:16am UTC
2 Bedrooms
71 Crescent St
Yaphank, NY
Updated January 3 at 11:22am UTC
1 Bedroom
342 W Forest Rd
Mastic Beach
Mastic Beach, NY
Updated January 3 at 11:19am UTC
3 Bedrooms
63 Fuoco Rd
North Bellport
Bellport, NY
Updated January 3 at 11:19am UTC
2 Bedrooms
12 Centerview Trl
Ridge, NY
Updated January 3 at 11:21am UTC
3 Bedrooms
Results within 5 miles of Shirley, NY
19 Bailey Ct
Middle Island
Middle Island, NY
Updated January 9 at 4:31am UTC
1 Bedroom
859 Spring Lake Dr
Middle Island
Middle Island, NY
Updated January 3 at 11:19am UTC
3 Bedrooms
69 Bailey Ct
Middle Island
Middle Island, NY
Updated January 16 at 1:46am UTC
1 Bedroom
19 Bellport Ln
Bellport, NY
Updated January 18 at 6:57pm UTC
1 Bedroom
291 Smith Rd
Shirley, NY
Updated January 3 at 11:21am UTC
3 Bedrooms
4 Abby Ln
Mastic Beach
Shirley, NY
Updated January 3 at 11:19am UTC
3 Bedrooms
54 Overlook Dr
Mastic Beach
Mastic Beach, NY
Updated January 17 at 6:50pm UTC
3 Bedrooms
53 Old Neck Rd
Center Moriches
Center Moriches, NY
Updated January 10 at 5:37pm UTC
3 Bedrooms
Apartment List detective logo

Keep Looking!

Try removing some filters or broadening your
search area to see more results.

Apartment List detective logo

Zoom in to see more.

Trying to get a feel for the larger area? No problem.
When you're ready, zoom in again to see pins and listings.

Apartment List sad heart

Something went wrong.

Please try your search again or reload the page.

City Guide
Moving to Shirley

New York City, as a rule, is a very expensive city. In fact, it's one of the top-three most expensive cities in the United States, so it stands to reason that moving to Shirley won't be cheap. However, Shirley is nowhere near one of the most expensive communities in New York, with an average home value that is less than 10 percent of the New York average. The percentage of vacant rental apartments is 6 percent, which is not bad for this state.

Make a Plan:

Before you start your hunt for an apartment, prepare a list of your requirements. While most people consider themselves lucky to find an apartment to rent in New York, where the competition for housing is fierce, that's no reason to settle for a sub-par apartment -- after all, you will have to spend at least some time there.

What You Need:

Most landlords will need a security deposit, the first months payment, a letter (or two) of reference, proof of income, and permission to check your credit. Adding in a healthy dose of charm won't hurt.

Where to Live in Shirley

Where you live in a community affects your enjoyment and perception of the city overall. Shirley is no different, and the prices for renting an apartment differ according to neighborhood. Here are some details about a few Shirley neighborhoods.

Town Center: Welcome to this neighborhood, where the bulk of the residential homes are made up of small apartment buildings, and single-family homes.

Moriches Middle Island Rd/William Floyd Pky: This neighborhood is a little more expensive than Town Center, with more single-family homes than most neighborhoods in the nation.

William Floyd Pky/Parkwood Dr: This is a waterfront neighborhood, which serves as a draw for residents who want to live near the water.

Life in Shirley

One of Shirley's best attributes is its proximity to water, which attracts tourists, visitors, and people who want to enjoy the scenery, seafood, and water-related activities. Sound like you? Come on home.