52 Apartments for rent in Shirley, NY

Top picks for you

Discover more top places in Shirley
Starting at $2,200
Updated 3 days ago
45 Fairview Dr
45 Fairview Dr
Shirley, NY
3 Bedrooms
$2,200
Starting at $1,450
Updated 13 days ago
150 River Rd
150 River Rd
Shirley, NY
1 Bedroom
$1,450
Featured
Starting at $2,525
Updated 3 hrs ago
The Reserve at the Boulevard
1 Reserve Drive
Yaphank, NY
1 Bedroom
Ask
2 Bedrooms
$2,525
1-2 bedroom apartments with lush organic aesthetic. In-unit laundry and patio or balcony vistas. Maintenance on call 24/7. Parking, gym and pool available on site. Pets welcome.
more...
Starting at $2,500
Updated 9 days ago
196 Mckinley Dr
196 Mckinley Dr
Mastic Beach, NY
3 Bedrooms
$2,500
Starting at $2,500
Updated 9 days ago
94 Magnolia Dr
94 Magnolia Dr
Mastic Beach, NY
3 Bedrooms
$2,500
Starting at $1,800
Updated 1 month ago
229 Forest Rd
229 Forest Rd
Mastic Beach, NY
2 Bedrooms
$1,800
Featured
Starting at $1,855
Updated 2 hrs ago
Rosemont Brookhaven
1220 Orchid Cir
Bellport, NY
1 Bedroom
$1,855
2 Bedrooms
$2,292
3 Bedrooms
$2,600
Community has a tennis court, gym, car wash area, and games room. Units are recently renovated with granite counters and in-unit laundry. Extra storage. Quiet setting near Sills Road shopping. Access to Sunrise Hwy and I-495.
more...
Starting at $2,400
Updated 23 hrs ago
790 Middle Country Rd
790 Middle Country Rd
Ridge, NY
3 Bedrooms
$2,400
Starting at $2,000
Updated 3 days ago
402 Village Cir
402 Village Cir
Manorville, NY
2 Bedrooms
$2,000
Starting at $3,000
Updated 7 days ago
2 Nesaquake Trl
2 Nesaquake Trl
Ridge, NY
4 Bedrooms
$3,000
Starting at $2,800
Updated 8 days ago
51 Rustic Ave
51 Rustic Ave
Medford, NY
3 Bedrooms
$2,800
Starting at $1,350
Updated 1 month ago
32B Limetree Dr
32B Limetree Dr
Manorville, NY
1 Bedroom
$1,350
Starting at $20,000
Updated 4 months ago
53 Old Neck Rd
53 Old Neck Rd
Center Moriches, NY
3 Bedrooms
$20,000
Featured
Starting at $1,867
Updated 7 hrs ago
Enclave at Charles Pond
1 Charles Pond Dr
Coram, NY
1 Bedroom
$1,867
2 Bedrooms
$2,260
Coram apartments available in the heart of Suffolk County. This pet-friendly community is situated on 41 private acres with resort-style amenities, including an on-site pool and gym. Apartments feature patios, hardwood floors and walk-in closets.
more...
Featured
Starting at $2,181
Updated 17 hrs ago
New Village at Patchogue
1 Village Green
East Patchogue, NY
1 Bedroom
$2,181
2 Bedrooms
$2,544
3 Bedrooms
Ask
Modern layouts featuring community amenities like green roofs, safe parking, swimming pool, sundeck and fully equipped fitness center. Conveniently located near art, music, shopping and restaurant venues.
more...
Featured
Starting at $2,169
Updated 17 hrs ago
The Point at Pine Ridge
1 Avalon Pines Dr
Coram, NY
1 Bedroom
$2,169
2 Bedrooms
$2,331
Rocky Point State Pine Preserve and three shopping malls surround one- and two-bedroom luxury apartment units. Private balconies and access to tennis court and golf course.
more...
Starting at $1,550
Updated 3 hrs ago
114 E Lakewood St
114 E Lakewood St
Patchogue, NY
1 Bedroom
$1,550
Starting at $1,800
Updated 3 hrs ago
244 Fairharbor Dr
244 Fairharbor Dr
Patchogue, NY
2 Bedrooms
$1,800
Starting at $2,300
Updated 3 hrs ago
99 Everett St
99 Everett St
Patchogue, NY
3 Bedrooms
$2,300
Starting at $2,000
Updated 3 hrs ago
111 Halesite Dr
111 Halesite Dr
Sound Beach, NY
2 Bedrooms
$2,000
Starting at $15,000
Updated 3 hrs ago
212 Creek Rd
212 Creek Rd
Wading River, NY
4 Bedrooms
$15,000
Starting at $2,400
Updated 11 hrs ago
229 Berkshire Dr
229 Berkshire Dr
Farmingville, NY
2 Bedrooms
$2,400
Starting at $1,200
Updated 15 hrs ago
3 Mauritz
3 Mauritz
Middle Island, NY
1 Bedroom
$1,200
Starting at $1,250
Updated 1 day ago
21 Griffin Dr
21 Griffin Dr
Mount Sinai, NY
1 Bedroom
$1,250

You Choose

Find your perfect apartment
Make your results better and choose your own preferences.

Explore by Map

See apartments close to work or school
City GuideShirley

Surprise, surprise! Shirley, New York isn't named after a woman, but for developer Walter T. Shirley, who realized his dream of making the community a haven of affordable housing options.

With a small, cozy feel, Shirley is the place for those who prefer life in a tight-knit community. Interestingly, Shirley is not a city, village, or town. Instead, this little community, home to just under 30,000 people, is a hamlet. This might conjure images of Shakespearean melodrama, but the enclave actually has quite a bit going for itself, not least of which is a price tag far lower than New York City's.

Moving to Shirley

New York City, as a rule, is a very expensive city. In fact, it's one of the top-three most expensive cities in the United States, so it stands to reason that moving to Shirley won't be cheap. However, Shirley is nowhere near one of the most expensive communities in New York, with an average home value that is less than 10 percent of the New York average. The percentage of vacant rental apartments is 6 percent, which is not bad for this state.

Make a Plan:

Before you start your hunt for an apartment, prepare a list of your requirements. While most people consider themselves lucky to find an apartment to rent in New York, where the competition for housing is fierce, that's no reason to settle for a sub-par apartment -- after all, you will have to spend at least some time there.

What You Need:

Most landlords will need a security deposit, the first months payment, a letter (or two) of reference, proof of income, and permission to check your credit. Adding in a healthy dose of charm won't hurt.

Where to Live in Shirley

Where you live in a community affects your enjoyment and perception of the city overall. Shirley is no different, and the prices for renting an apartment differ according to neighborhood. Here are some details about a few Shirley neighborhoods.

Town Center: Welcome to this neighborhood, where the bulk of the residential homes are made up of small apartment buildings, and single-family homes.

Moriches Middle Island Rd/William Floyd Pky: This neighborhood is a little more expensive than Town Center, with more single-family homes than most neighborhoods in the nation.

William Floyd Pky/Parkwood Dr: This is a waterfront neighborhood, which serves as a draw for residents who want to live near the water.

Life in Shirley

One of Shirley's best attributes is its proximity to water, which attracts tourists, visitors, and people who want to enjoy the scenery, seafood, and water-related activities. Sound like you? Come on home.

Personalize your results.
How many bedrooms do you want?
Studio
1 bed
2 bed
3+ bed
Next →