Start your Bay Shore search
How many bedrooms do you need?

Pet Friendly Apartments for Rent in Bay Shore, NY

5 rentals available
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 26
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 1
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 2
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 3
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 4
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 5
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 6
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 7
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 8
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 9
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 10
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 11
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 12
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 13
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 14
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 15
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 16
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 17
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 18
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 19
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 20
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 21
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 22
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 23
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 24
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 25
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 26
    • 227 4th Avenue Gallery 1

    1 of 26

    227 4th Avenue

    $2,850
    227 4th Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (516) 978-1969
    1 unit available
    1 bed
    Amenities

    In unit laundry, Granite counters, Pet friendly, Parking, Stainless steel, and Elevator

    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 32
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 1
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 2
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 3
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 4
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 5
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 6
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 7
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 8
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 9
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 10
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 11
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 12
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 13
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 14
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 15
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 16
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 17
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 18
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 19
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 20
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 21
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 22
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 23
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 24
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 25
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 26
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 27
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 28
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 29
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 30
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 31
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 32
    • 1396 Illinois Avenue Gallery 1

    1 of 32

    1396 Illinois Avenue

    $4,200
    1396 Illinois Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (631) 433-1128
    1 unit available
    3 bed
    Amenities

    Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Parking, Recently renovated, Stainless steel, Extra storage + more

  • 41 Pinebrook Place

    $2,200
    41 Pinebrook Place, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (631) 459-6953
    1 unit available
    1 bed
    Amenities

    Parking and Range

  • 191 Newbrook Lane

    $2,350
    191 Newbrook Lane, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (631) 459-6953
    1 unit available
    1 bed
    Amenities

    In unit laundry, Parking, Internet access, Oven, and Refrigerator

  • Featured Unit 1
    Best market deals
    These units are the best deal in town.

  • 130 5th Avenue

    $3,195
    130 5th Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (631) 397-4562
    1 unit available
    3 bed
    Amenities

    In unit laundry, Pet friendly, Parking, Recently renovated, Microwave, and Range

More Rental Options

Bedrooms
Amenities
Cities
Counties
Colleges

Frequently Asked Questions

City Guide for Bay Shore, NY

Leave the racket of New York City behind and head out to Bay Shore, a city filled with white sand beaches that has served as home to LL Cool J and former San Francisco politician Harvey Milk.

Bay Shore’s history can be traced back to its founding in 1697

View Bay Shore City Guide