Start your Short Hills apartment search!
Select how many bedrooms you want.
S
Studio
1
Bed
2
Beds
3+
Beds

77 Apartments for rent in Short Hills, NJ

Read Guide >
Last updated October 20 at 1:27AM
Results within 1 miles of Short Hills, NJ
Results within 5 miles of Short Hills, NJ
70 Carlton St
East Orange
East Orange, NJ
Updated September 30 at 9:53AM UTC
1 Bedroom
$1,050
758 S 20th St
West Side
Newark, NJ
Updated October 20 at 1:27AM UTC
3 Bedrooms
$1,300
508 Bailey Avenue
, NJ
Updated September 15 at 12:01AM UTC
2 Bedrooms
$2,000
34 Oakland Road
, NJ
Updated September 18 at 5:29PM UTC
4 Bedrooms
$4,999
121 Elliot Pl
Orange
East Orange, NJ
Updated October 12 at 1:37AM UTC
2 Bedrooms
$1,595
344 OLD SHORT HILLS ROAD
Short Hills
Short Hills, NJ
Updated October 7 at 1:42AM UTC
3 Bedrooms
$4,800
38 MAIN ST
, NJ
Updated September 15 at 12:03AM UTC
1 Bedroom
$1,900
245 MAIN ST 5A
, NJ
Updated October 14 at 2:17AM UTC
2 Bedrooms
$2,450
830 S 19th St
Upper Clinton Hill
Newark, NJ
Updated October 19 at 11:29AM UTC
5 Bedrooms
$1,500
Apartment List detective logo

Keep Looking!

Try removing some filters or broadening your
search area to see more results.

Apartment List detective logo

Zoom in to see more.

Trying to get a feel for the larger area? No problem.
When you're ready, zoom in again to see pins and listings.

Apartment List sad heart

Something went wrong.

Please try your search again or reload the page.

City Guide
Short Hills
Moving to Short Hills

Life here may be peaches and cream, but finding a property rental is more difficult than Manhattan. This is one of the region's most desirable locations, so know that while it's very feasible to locate home rentals in Short Hills, you still have your work cut out for you.

Trends That Don't Help Renters

Roughly 6 percent of locals rent, which is well below New Jersey's average of nearly 34 percent. Additionally, Short Hills is truly short on available housing, and renters must bring their best game if they plan on actually landing a home. This is just reality in the popular Short Hills. It's like when the host puts good appetizers out at a party and they are gone by the time you get back from the bathroom. Don't waste time in the bathroom. Grab something if it's there.

Should You Own?

Short Hills is an owner's market and you should consider buying, but only if your plans are definite and you are ready. If not, renting is entirely possible, but you won't have nearly as many options; renting, though, does give you flexibility to test a home and area without the risk of owning.

Houses and More Houses

If you are coming to Short Hills looking for an apartment to rent, reconsider your plan. Detached houses total over 95 percent of homes here. As stated, Short Hills doesn't showcase a lot of openings, so just searching for one-bedroom apartments (if that's what you want) won't yield many results; expand that search to include houses and see what you get. You can still get a flat, however, as there are a few complexes, but there are way more houses.

Wait for Your Opportunity... And Pounce

When an opening arises, pounce before another renter does. Rental listings don't float on the market in Short Hills for long. Summer sees the most rental turnover, and that's the best time to find an apartment or house. The key is to make inquiries with complexes, brokers, and landlords beforehand as to when leases are expiring; ask to tour a few of those places as soon as possible, even if the current tenant is watching TV in the living room at the time.

Making Sure You Get the Pad

Landlords and management companies in Short Hills aren't desperate for renters, and will refuse you if they aren't certain you will pay every month. Upfront costs such as one month's rent, a deposit, and application fees should be in your pocket, ready to be handed over as soon as you think a place suits you. Voluntarily offering to provide a credit report as well as landlord references will make you stand out from other potential tenants.

Short Hills Neighborhoods and Communities

At just over 5.2 miles, you may think it doesn't matter where you live in Short Hills, Oh, it does! Your 'hood choice can impact your access to transit, parks, restaurants, or shops. That is no small matter.

Deerfield: Mostly car dependent, this area is near South Mountain Reservation and Old Short Hills Park. It is simply a stunning residential area.

Canoe Brook: A somewhat walkable part of town, this neighborhood features the iconic Short Hills Mall, Canoe Brook Country Club, and ample restaurants. It's also near the Short Hills train station.

Glenwood: A bit less walkable than Canoe Brook, this area offers the widest variety of housing. If you desire an apartment or condo for rent, this is the spot in Short Hills. The Cora Hartshorn Arboretum is located in this neighborhood and so is the train station.

Fox Hill Preserve: The area around this preserve is mostly houses, but these are the kinds of pads that will have you drooling.

Living in Short Hills

While Short Hills is close enough to New York City that you can almost hear it roaring, this town does still sleep at night. That's a good thing, especially when you consider there's so much to do here during the day. Short Hills may not have all that the five boroughs do, but it certainly competes. A show at Paper Mill Playhouse may make you forget about Broadway. A stroll through the Cora Hartshorn Arboretum and Bird Sanctuary pleases just as Central Park does. The Mall at Short Hills is every bit the shopper's paradise that Saks Fifth Avenue is. When you just want a meal with new pals, eateries abound near Route 24. When you feel like golfing, hack around at one of the area's many courses. Once you return home, you'll find that Short Hills may lack the sizzle of New York City, but it has all the amenities. On top of that, living here offers peace from the madness of the big city. If you ever crave that madness, take the train to Penn Station, and unload in Manhattan. Then come back, kick back, soak in the scenery of the South Mountain Reservation, and enjoy life in the marvelous land of Short Hills.