The Best Indianapolis Neighborhoods for Every Lifestyle in 2025

Indianapolis’s best neighborhoods include Nora - Far Northside for families seeking suburban life (A- public school grade), Downtown Indianapolis for walkability and young professionals (98 Walk Score and 99 Bike Score), and University Heights for students (good crime stats and high diversity).

In this guide, we’ll go over how to choose a neighborhood based on your commute, lifestyle, rent budget, commute, and more. We’ve compiled a comprehensive ranking of the best places to live in Indianapolis, evaluating safety, livability, transit, and amenities.

A Note on Data: We used internal data and cross-referenced with neighborhood data from Rent.com and Zumper to give you the most accurate snapshot of rents across Indianapolis as of August 2025. We also referenced data from walkscore.com, niche.com, and crimegrade.org to help you understand each neighborhood as a whole.

What are the most walkable Indianapolis neighborhoods?

Downtown Indianapolis

• Best For: Renters who want a fast-paced, walkable lifestyle with access to nightlife, sports, and cultural attractions.
• Walk Score: 98
• Bike Score: 99
• Transit Score: 66
• Diversity Rating: A-
• Average two-bedroom apartment rent: $1,730
• Crime Grade: Below average

Downtown Indianapolis is the city’s core for action, with an 81 Walk Score and an average two-bedroom rent of $1,730. Renters here enjoy easy access to everything from Pacers and Colts games to indie theaters, festivals, and a dynamic food and brewery scene—often all within a few blocks. Mass Ave and the Wholesale District are hotspots for dining, nightlife, and boutique shopping, while the Cultural Trail and scenic canal paths make biking a viable alternative to driving.

Commuting downtown is as easy as stepping outside, especially for professionals working in tech, finance, or state government. While public transit leaves a lot to be desired, it does offer a few options, but since you’re already downtown, hopefully you can skip it. The trade-off for living downtown? Rents are higher, and there’s occasional congestion during major events. But for those who thrive in an active, urban environment, Downtown Indy delivers.

Fountain Square

• Best For: Creative renters and couples looking for quirky charm, indie entertainment, and walkable nightlife.
• Walk Score: 73
• Bike Score: 89
• Transit Score: 41
• Diversity Rating: B+
• Average two-bedroom apartment rent: $1,890
• Crime Grade: Below average

Fountain Square blends vintage charm with creative flair, think restored theaters, tattoo parlors, vintage record shops, and late-night pizza by the slice. With a 73 Walk Score and average two-bedroom rent of $1,890, this neighborhood appeals to artists, musicians, and those drawn to offbeat culture. The square itself hosts regular art walks, live shows, and street festivals, while quirky bars and indie cafes line Virginia Avenue, a major bike-friendly corridor into Downtown.

While transit options are limited and parking can be tight on weekends, the area is well-connected by the Cultural Trail, making commuting by bike both fast and scenic. It’s a top choice for those who want personality and walkability without being directly in the heart of downtown traffic.

Meridian Kessler

• Best For: Families and professionals who want quiet, tree-lined streets, historic homes, and a neighborhood feel with urban access.
• Walk Score: 60
• Bike Score: 65
• Transit Score: 41
• Diversity Rating: B+
• Average two-bedroom apartment rent: $1,888
• Crime Grade: Below average

Meridian Kessler offers a suburban vibe within city limits, making it a favorite for renters who want space, charm, and a strong sense of community. With wide sidewalks, mature trees, and well-preserved architecture, it’s ideal for morning jogs, dog walks, or strolling to locally loved spots like cafes. The average rent for a two-bedroom here is $1,888, and while the Walk Score is 60, many essentials, from parks to grocery stores, are still easily accessible on foot or by bike.

Although public transit is limited, commuting by car to Broad Ripple, Downtown, or Butler University is quick and manageable. The neighborhood also offers more peace and quiet than trendier nightlife-heavy districts, making it appealing for those who prioritize lifestyle balance over late nights. It’s especially well-suited to renters seeking a residential feel with occasional city perks just a few minutes away.

What are the best Indianapolis neighborhoods for families?

Nora - Far Northside

• Best For: Families seeking quiet suburban streets, strong schools, and proximity to retail and green space.
• Public School Grade: A-
• Overall Niche.com Grade: A
• Average two-bedroom apartment rent: $1,155
• Crime Grade: Average

Nora – Far Northside pairs an A- public school rating, A Niche.com grade, and affordable 2BR rent of $1,155, making it a go-to for families who want top-tier schools without moving to the suburbs. Zoned to high-performing public schools and near private options like Sycamore School, the area is known for its peaceful cul-de-sacs, large lots, and proximity to the Monon Trail.

Just minutes from Keystone Crossing, Nora gives families quick access to shopping, restaurants, and weekend activities, without the high prices or long commutes. While crime is average for Indianapolis, the neighborhood’s stable, residential feel and long-standing appeal make it a consistent favorite among parents.

Southern Dunes

• Best For: Parents looking for newer housing, quiet streets, and strong school performance in a growing area.
• Public School Grade: A-
• Overall Niche.com Grade: A-
• Average two-bedroom apartment rent: $1,567
• Crime Grade: Above average

Southern Dunes combines an A- school rating, A- Niche.com score, and mid-range 2BR rent of $1,567, appealing to families looking for a more suburban lifestyle inside city limits. With newer homes, golf course views, and parks throughout the area, it’s ideal for those who want space, modern amenities, and a quieter daily pace.

The neighborhood is zoned to several well-rated elementary and middle schools, and it draws parents who prefer planned communities and newer developments. While the crime grade is above average, many streets feel insulated due to limited through-traffic and a strong HOA presence. Commuting to downtown is manageable, and weekend errands are easy thanks to nearby big-box retail and dining options.

Butler-Tarkington

• Best For: Families who value education, historic charm, and access to green space on a budget.
• Public School Grade: B-
• Overall Niche.com Grade: A+
• Average two-bedroom apartment rent: $965
• Crime Grade: Below average

Butler-Tarkington pairs a B- public school score with an A+ Niche.com rating and a very affordable 2BR rent of just $965, making it an excellent option for value-minded families. The neighborhood’s proximity to Butler University and parks like Holcomb Gardens and Tarkington Park provides plenty of green space, culture, and walkability in one of Indy’s most historic areas.

While schools are a mix of public and private options, many families are drawn to the strong community vibe, neighborhood events, and access to bike trails and local cafes. With a below-average crime grade and lower rents than nearby areas, it’s a standout for families who want city living with a residential feel.

What are the best Indianapolis neighborhoods for young adults?

Downtown Indianapolis

• Best For: Young professionals and students who want walkable nightlife, job access, and an active city lifestyle.
• Transit Score: 66
• Diversity Rating: A-
• Average two-bedroom apartment rent: $1,730
• Crime Grade: Below average

Downtown Indianapolis has a Transit Score of 66, a diversity rating of A-, and an average two-bedroom rent of $1,730. It’s one of the most active parts of the city, with plenty of bars, restaurants, coffee shops, and venues within walking or biking distance. Young professionals appreciate being near major employers, with plenty of apartment options close to the Statehouse, IU Health, and tech hubs.

There’s also nearby access to the Cultural Trail, sports arenas, and the city’s best events and festivals. While it's more expensive than some nearby areas, living downtown means shorter commutes, busy weekends, and always having something to do within a few blocks.

Garfield Park

• Best For: Renters who want affordability, green space, and a slower pace close to the city.
• Transit Score: 35
• Diversity Rating: A-
• Average two-bedroom apartment rent: $900
• Crime Grade: Below average

Garfield Park offers a lower cost of living with a 2BR rent averaging just $900, along with a Transit Score of 35 and A- diversity. It’s named after the city’s oldest public park, which is also one of its best. The park has trails, a conservatory, and an amphitheater that hosts concerts and movie nights, all within walking distance for many renters.

The neighborhood attracts younger residents who want space, a creative atmosphere, and a more residential feel without being too far from downtown. It’s not as transit-connected, but bike and car commutes are quick. Affordable rent and community events make it a smart pick for students, artists, and anyone looking for more space on a budget.

Fountain Square

• Best For: Young professionals seeking trendy apartments, restaurants, and a polished urban vibe.
• Transit Score: 41
• Diversity Rating: B+
• Average two-bedroom apartment rent: $1,890
• Crime Grade: Below average

Fountain Square has a Transit Score of 41, B+ diversity, and one of the city’s highest average 2BR rents at $1,890. It’s a walkable, artsy neighborhood filled with murals, music venues, galleries, and bars. Young adults are drawn to its character—everything from boutique shops to live performances is right around the corner.

While public transit is limited, the neighborhood connects easily to downtown by bike or rideshare. Renters here are often paying for access to the area's unique energy and local businesses. If you want an apartment above a coffee shop or near live music every weekend, Fountain Square delivers.

What are the best Indianapolis neighborhoods for students?

University Heights

• Best For: Living next to the University of Indianapolis with affordable rent and walkable access to campus.
• Average two-bedroom apartment rent: $984
• Proximity to Universities: Adjacent to the University of Indianapolis, 15-minute drive to IUPUI (Indiana University - Purdue University)
• Diversity Rating: A-
• Crime Grade: Average

University Heights stands out for its proximity to the University of Indianapolis and average 2BR rent of just $960, making it one of the most affordable student neighborhoods in the city. Most housing is within walking distance to campus, with a mix of older apartments, small rental homes, and duplexes tailored to students.

The neighborhood is residential, with easy access to fast food, convenience stores, and study spots. While nightlife is minimal, students can get to Downtown or Fountain Square in 10–15 minutes for more options. For those who prioritize price and convenience over amenities, University Heights checks all the boxes.

Butler-Tarkington

• Best For: Students at Butler University who want a quiet, residential neighborhood with green space.
• Average two-bedroom apartment rent: $965
• Proximity to Universities: On campus at Butler University, 10-minute drive to IUPUI
• Diversity Rating: A-
• Crime Grade: Below average

Butler-Tarkington is near Butler University and offers a neighborhood feel with tree-lined streets, front porches, and local coffee shops. With an average two-bedroom rent of around $965, it’s one of the more budget-friendly areas close to a major private university. Students can walk or bike to class and have access to green spaces, such as Holcomb Gardens and Tarkington Park.

It’s quieter than other student-heavy areas and more focused on day-to-day life than nightlife. That calm, combined with a below-average crime rate, makes it appealing to undergrads, graduate students, and student-athletes who want to stay close to campus without distractions.

Near Eastside

• Best For: IUPUI students looking for lower rent and a short commute to Downtown.
• Average two-bedroom apartment rent: $1,541
• Proximity to Universities: 10-minute drive or bike ride to IUPUI, 15 minutes to Ivy Tech
• Diversity Rating: A
• Crime Grade: Below average

Near Eastside offers students at IUPUI and Ivy Tech a budget-conscious option just outside of Downtown, with an average 2BR rent of $895 and a strong A diversity rating. It’s close enough to campus for a fast bike or bus ride, but far enough to find lower rent and more space.

The neighborhood is evolving, with renovated homes, community centers, and growing retail options along East Washington Street. While it’s still an up-and-coming area, the mix of affordability and proximity makes it a practical choice for students who don’t mind a slightly longer commute in exchange for a lower monthly cost.

Find Your Perfect Indianapolis Apartment

Indianapolis offers renters a taste of the good life in the Midwest, but selecting a neighborhood should be based on your priorities.

• Best Overall for Urban Living: Downtown Indianapolis – walkable, bikeable, and filled with entertainment, dining, and major employers.
• Best for Families: Nora – Far Northside – strong public schools, quiet streets, and access to shopping and parks.
• Best for Young Professionals: Fountain Square – artsy, social, and full of nightlife, music venues, and local character.
• Best for Students: University Heights – affordable rent right next to the University of Indianapolis with quick access to IUPUI.
• Most Walkable: Downtown Indianapolis and Fountain Square – both neighborhoods offer high walk and bike scores, with vibrant amenities close to home.

It doesn’t matter if you’re interested in walkability, nightlife, or affordability in Indianapolis; the city has a lot to offer and a neighborhood that (hopefully) suits your lifestyle. Find your next rental unit today.

Take our Apartment List quiz to find your perfect match in 90 seconds.

Frequently Asked Questions About Indianapolis’s Best Neighborhoods

What is the safest neighborhood in Indianapolis?

Neighborhoods like Southern Dunes and Nora – Far Northside tend to have lower crime rates than other parts of the city, especially when looking at violent incidents.

What are the most walkable areas in Indianapolis?

Downtown Indianapolis is the most walkable area, but it scores rather low for public transit (66 Transit Score). Fountain Square also offers walkability near the downtown area.

Where do creatives live in Indianapolis?

Artists are typically drawn to areas with a rich music, art, and cultural scene, such as Fountain Square, Broad Ripple, and Garfield Park.

Where do young professionals live in Indianapolis?

Young adults often move to neighborhoods like Fountain Square, Downtown Indianapolis, and Garfield Park, where they have access to restaurants, bars, coffee shops, and local arts scenes.

What are the quietest neighborhoods in Indianapolis?

Southern Dunes, Nora – Far Northside, and Hill Valley offer more of a suburban vibe, with quieter streets and family-friendly settings away from downtown noise.

Is Indianapolis a good city for remote workers?

Yes, many areas of Indianapolis cater to remote workers. Neighborhoods like Fountain Square, Downtown, and Broad Ripple offer coworking spaces with reliable Wi-Fi, libraries, and convenient commutes.

What’s the cost of living like in Indianapolis compared to other major cities?

Indianapolis is more affordable than nearby Midwest cities, such as Chicago, Illinois. Housing costs in Chicago are 28% more expensive than in Indianapolis.

What is the average rent in Indianapolis in 2025?

As of mid-2025, the average rent in Indianapolis is $1,285 for a one-bedroom unit and $1,514 for a two-bedroom unit, according to Apartment List data.

What neighborhood has the best access to public transit in Indianapolis?

Downtown Indianapolis offers renters the best access to public transportation and bike access, with multiple bus lines and walkable streets.

Is Indianapolis affordable for renters?

Yes, Indianapolis is affordable for renters, especially in neighborhoods like Butler-Tarkington and Nora-Far Northside. In these neighborhoods, the average rent is significantly lower than the national average of $2,102 (data from Apartment List).

Using the 30% rule, a renter living in Butler-Tarkington (where the average rent for a two-bedroom apartment is $965) would only have to make around $3,225 per month. MIT’s current Living Wage Calculator estimates that an adult must earn $20.81 per hour or $43,280 per year to support themselves.

Which part of Indianapolis is the best?

It depends on your lifestyle. Downtown is best for walkability and access to events, Nora is ideal for families, and Fountain Square stands out for creative energy and nightlife.