How much is rent in Fire Island?

In Fire Island, the average rent is + for a studio, $25,000+ for a 1-bedroom, $18,000+ for a 2-bedroom, and + for a 3-bedroom.* *Based on base prices that don’t include fees

How can I find a pet-friendly apartment in Fire Island?

You can use the pet-friendly filter to find apartments that allow pets.

How much should I pay for rent in Fire Island?

The answer to this question depends on your household income and a couple of other factors. You can use our Rent Calculator to figure out how much you should spend on rent in Fire Island.

How can I find off-campus housing in Fire Island?

You can use the off-campus housing filters to find apartments near colleges located in or around Fire Island. Some of the colleges and universities in the area include Suffolk County Community College , and Farmingdale State College .

Start your Fire Island search

How many bedrooms do you need?

Apartments for Rent in Fire Island, NY

58 rentals available

31 Homesite
$7,500
31 Homesite Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Pool, Playground, and Basketball court
Seaside Serenity
Luxurious living in Fire Island's Seaview
Enjoy the best of Fire Island at 31 Homesite Avenue. This fabulous property in Seaview offers stunning bay views from a terrific rooftop deck, making it perfect for admiring beautiful summer sunsets. Residents highly praise the home's cleanliness and comfort, which are complemented by amenities like in-unit laundry and a dishwasher.
Recently updated units
7 E End Walk
$5,000
7 East End Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
3 bed
Amenities
Refrigerator
Watersport Haven
Perfect escape for water lovers
7 E End Walk offers magnificent sunset views and a serene retreat. The property is a true paradise for water sports and fishing enthusiasts, making it ideal for those seeking adventure on the water. With features such as separate entrances and amenities for beach comfort, this property promises an unforgettable stay.
Recently updated units
11 Seneca Street
$7,000
11 Seneca Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, and Refrigerator
Beach Retreat
Charming Fire Island Beach Lifestyle
Discover a true beach haven at 11 Seneca Street. This delightful property features ample space and fantastic outdoor amenities, such as private decking with an outdoor shower, bicycles, and beach chairs to enhance your island experience. It's a perfect choice for those seeking both relaxation and proximity to Fire Island's coastal attractions.
Recently updated units
38 Oneida Street
$13,500
38 Oneida Street, Fire Island, NY 11770
1 unit available
5 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Fireplace, and Refrigerator
Beachfront Paradise
Stunning ocean views and beachfront serenity
38 Oneida Street, nestled in Fire Island, NY, offers an unbeatable beachfront location with breathtaking ocean views. Enjoy a seamless blend of comfort and convenience with amenities like in-unit laundry, a dishwasher, and a refrigerator. Residents praise the property for its well-maintained condition and the outstanding wraparound deck views.
Recently updated units
Best market deals
These units are the best deal in town.
5 Atlantic Avenue 3 Bed
3 Beds • 1 Bath
Total monthly rent
Ask
Available
Now
4 Surfview Walk 3 Bed
3 Beds • 2 Baths
Total monthly rent
Ask
Available
Now
33 Sextant Walk 0 Bed
Studio • 1 Bath
Total monthly rent
Ask
Available
Now
19 Champlain Street 4 Bed
4 Beds • 2 Baths
Total monthly rent
Ask
Available
Now
7 E End Walk 3 Bed
3 Beds • 2 Baths
Total monthly rent
Ask
Available
Now
25 Atlantic Avenue
$7,500
25 Atlantic Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
3 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Recently renovated, Pool, and Hot tub
Recently updated units
18 Erie Street
$5,300
18 Erie Street, Fire Island, NY 11770
1 unit available
2 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Hot tub, Bbq/grill, and Refrigerator
Outdoor Retreat
Immaculate getaway, fully stocked for relaxation.
18 Erie Street in Fire Island offers an immaculate setting for a peaceful escape. The property features a spacious deck with ample seating and a private patio, making it perfect for outdoor dining and relaxation. Residents adore the home's unique amenities, including six bikes and beach chairs, along with a private hot tub for ultimate leisure.
Recently updated units
35 Beachwold Avenue
$6,000
35 Beachwold Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(917) 734-6624
1 unit available
5 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Fireplace, and Refrigerator
Seaside Escape
Spacious retreat steps from Fire Island's serene beaches.
Experience the perfect beachside living at 35 Beachwold Avenue. The ample space in this charming property offers comfort for large families. Residents rave about the convenient guest cottage and the property's effortless proximity to the beach. Enjoy the serene and family-friendly atmosphere of the surrounding Seaview community.
Recently updated units
9 Beachwold
$35,000
9 Beachwold Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(917) 734-6624
1 unit available
3 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Internet access, and Refrigerator
Seaside Retreat
Stunning wrap-around deck with scenic bay views.
9 Beachwold is a charming haven on Fire Island with a scenic wrap-around deck offering breathtaking sunrise and sunset views. Its excellent location close to the beach and local attractions enhances convenience and enjoyment. The spacious interior, complete with a well-stocked kitchen, promises a comfortable stay, while amenities like Direct TV, WiFi, and provided bicycles add to the overall experience.
Recently updated units
25 Sloop Walk
$15,000
25 Sloop Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 988-9059
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Pool, and Refrigerator
Seaside Escape
Relax near Ocean Beach's vibrant attractions.
Immerse yourself in this stunning new build in the Summer Club community. Enjoy the spacious, contemporary open floor plan and take advantage of the heated swimming pool. Simply step out your door for easy access to Ocean Beach's vibrant shops and restaurants.
Recently updated units
49 E Bayview Walk
$25,000
49 Bayview Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 988-9059
1 unit available
1 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Pool, Bbq/grill, and Refrigerator
Bayfront Bliss
Perfect Summer Retreat with Bay Views
Experience life's finest moments with breathtaking bayfront views and exclusive beach access. Enjoy the vibrant ambiance near the ferry, leading to an array of dining options. Fully furnished with amenities like a BBQ, outdoor shower, and kayak, this spot guarantees an unforgettable summer getaway.
Recently updated units
Luxury apartments
Top units for an elevated lifestyle.
37 Kelp Walk 4 Bed
4 Beds • 2 Baths
Total monthly rent
Ask
Available
Now
9 Beachwold 3 Bed
3 Beds • 2 Baths
Total monthly rent
Ask
Available
Now
42 Evergreen 4 Bed
4 Beds • 2 Baths
Total monthly rent
Ask
Available
Now
30 Gale Walk 2 Bed
2 Beds • 1 Bath
Total monthly rent
Ask
Available
Now
50 East End Walk 3 Bed
3 Beds • 3 Baths
Total monthly rent
Ask
Available
Now
39 Seneca Street
$12,000
39 Seneca Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
1 unit available
5 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Fireplace, and Refrigerator
Oceanfront Living
Stunning ocean views from every window.
Experience true oceanfront living at 39 Seneca Street, Fire Island, with breathtaking ocean views from every window. The captivating open-layout design with cathedral ceilings creates an inviting atmosphere, enhanced by the home's stunning features like a sprawling deck and outdoor shower. Enjoy unparalleled access to the ocean just steps from your home.
Recently updated units
29 Superior Avenue
$24,000
29 Superior Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 495-0568
1 unit available
3 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Air conditioning, and Refrigerator
Beachside Retreat
Prime beachside location with modern amenities.
29 Superior Avenue is a beach lover's paradise, situated just three houses from the coastline. Enjoy the stunning location with easy access to Fire Island's beautiful beaches and local attractions. The property features modern conveniences like air conditioning, in-unit laundry, and a garage, complemented by an open layout that lets in plenty of natural light.
Recently updated units
7 Dehnhoff Walk
$20,000
7 Dehnhoff Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
3 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Recently renovated, and Refrigerator
Recently updated units
39 Schooner
$8,000
39 Schooner Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
3 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Range, and Refrigerator
Recently updated units
44 Island Walk
$7,500
44 Island Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Furnished, and Refrigerator
Recently updated units
320 Frigate Rdw
$7,000
320 Frigate Rdw, Fire Island, NY 11770
(917) 734-6624
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Air conditioning, Accessible, and Refrigerator
Bay Views
Stunning bay views enhance this Fire Island gem.
This Fire Island property features breathtaking bay views and a sleek new pergola area perfect for entertaining. Residents appreciate the convenience of 8 bikes and 12 beach chairs for effortless beach outings. Noteworthy for its handicap accessibility features, it’s a fantastic retreat for those seeking a harmonious blend of comfort and stunning scenery.
Recently updated units

Find an apartment for rent in Fire Island, NY

Searching for an apartment for rent in Fire Island, NY? Look no further! Apartment List will help you find a perfect apartment near you. There are 58 available rental units listed on Apartment List in Fire Island. Click on listings to see photos, floorplans, amenities, prices and availability, and much more!

The average rent in Fire Island is Ask for a studio, $25,000 for a one-bedroom apartment, and $18,000 for a two-bedroom apartment. If you are looking for a deal, keep an eye out for a red pulsing icon that indicates rent specials.

Tired of browsing? Take our personalized quiz. You’ll answer a couple of simple questions and we’ll put together a list of Fire Island apartments that are best for you. We’ll also factor in your commute, budget, and preferred amenities. Looking for a pet-friendly rental, or an apartment with in-unit washer and dryer? No problem, we’ll provide you with apartments that match that criteria.

You can trust Apartment List to help you find your next Fire Island, NY apartment rental! After all, everyone deserves a home they love.

Apartments for Rent in Fire Island, NY

31 Homesite

7 E End Walk

11 Seneca Street

38 Oneida Street

25 Atlantic Avenue

18 Erie Street

35 Beachwold Avenue

9 Beachwold

25 Sloop Walk

49 E Bayview Walk

39 Seneca Street

29 Superior Avenue

7 Dehnhoff Walk

39 Schooner

44 Island Walk

320 Frigate Rdw

More Rental Options

Find an apartment for rent in Fire Island, NY

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)