Join / Sign in
About usCareersRental TrendsSupport Privacy Policy Terms of Use Sitemap Sunny.comAccessibilityPartner PortalDo not sell or share my personal info
Equal Housing Opportunity
Join / Sign in
Start your Fire Island, NY search
How many bedrooms do you need?
  • Home/
  • NY/
  • Suffolk County/
  • Fire Island Apartments

Apartments for Rent in Fire Island, NY

61 rentals available
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
Start your Fire Island search
How many bedrooms do you need?

Find more rentals by

Amenities
  • Fire Island Luxury Apartments (24)
Account
Join / Sign in
Apartments for Rent
  • Apartments Near MeView apartments in your location
  • Renter HubMoving, insurance, payments, and more
  • Renter ToolsSmarter moves, less stress
  • Rate my RentIs your rent a good deal?
  • Cost of Living CalculatorCalculate your city’s cost of living
  • Rent CalculatorHow much rent should you pay?
  • Renter Life BlogNavigating life as a renter
  • Rent ReportFind the best time to move
Rental Management
  • A-List Smart PlatformAttract. Convert. Keep.
  • A-List MarketAttract move-ready renters
  • A-List NurtureConvert with Leasing AI
  • A-List ResidentMaintenance and Renewals AI
  • Research & Rental ToolsU.S. Rental Market and Renter Insights
  • Rental Management BlogTips on managing your rental
Join / Sign in
  • Explore
  • Short List
  • Join / Sign in

Listings

38 Oneida Street Gallery 1
1 of 14

38 Oneida Street

$13,500
38 Oneida Street, Fire Island, NY 11770
1 unit available
5 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Fireplace, and Refrigerator
Beachfront Paradise
Stunning ocean views and beachfront serenity
38 Oneida Street, nestled in Fire Island, NY, offers an unbeatable beachfront location with breathtaking ocean views. Enjoy a seamless blend of comfort and convenience with amenities like in-unit laundry, a dishwasher, and a refrigerator. Residents praise the property for its well-maintained condition and the outstanding wraparound deck views.
Recently updated units
31 Homesite Gallery 1
1 of 28

31 Homesite

$7,500
31 Homesite Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(917) 734-6624
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Pool, Playground, and Basketball court
Seaside Serenity
Luxurious living in Fire Island's Seaview
Enjoy the best of Fire Island at 31 Homesite Avenue. This fabulous property in Seaview offers stunning bay views from a terrific rooftop deck, making it perfect for admiring beautiful summer sunsets. Residents highly praise the home's cleanliness and comfort, which are complemented by amenities like in-unit laundry and a dishwasher.
Recently updated units
11 Seneca Street Gallery 1
1 of 17

11 Seneca Street

$7,000
11 Seneca Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, and Refrigerator
Beach Retreat
Charming Fire Island Beach Lifestyle
Discover a true beach haven at 11 Seneca Street. This delightful property features ample space and fantastic outdoor amenities, such as private decking with an outdoor shower, bicycles, and beach chairs to enhance your island experience. It's a perfect choice for those seeking both relaxation and proximity to Fire Island's coastal attractions.
Recently updated units
7 E End Walk Gallery 1
1 of 12

7 E End Walk

$5,000
7 East End Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
1 unit available
3 bed
Amenities
Fireplace and Refrigerator
Watersport Haven
Perfect escape for water lovers
7 E End Walk offers magnificent sunset views and a serene retreat. The property is a true paradise for water sports and fishing enthusiasts, making it ideal for those seeking adventure on the water. With features such as separate entrances and amenities for beach comfort, this property promises an unforgettable stay.
Recently updated units
31 Atlantic Avenue Gallery 1
1 of 32

31 Atlantic Avenue

$12,500
31 Atlantic Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 235-2774
1 unit available
5 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Dogs allowed, Stainless steel, Walk in closets + more
Recently updated units
25 Atlantic Avenue Gallery 1
1 of 15

25 Atlantic Avenue

$7,500
25 Atlantic Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(917) 734-6624
1 unit available
3 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Recently renovated, Pool, Tennis court + more
Recently updated units
35 Huron Street Gallery 1
1 of 11

35 Huron Street

$15,250
35 Huron Street, Fire Island, NY 11770
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Pool, and Refrigerator
Ocean Views
Luxury beachfront retreat with stunning ocean views.
Discover an oceanfront paradise at 35 Huron Street in Fire Island, NY. This contemporary retreat offers breathtaking ocean views and a stunning deck perfect for sunset watching. Residents rave about its welcoming atmosphere, well-maintained amenities, and easy beach access, ensuring a serene getaway.
Recently updated units
12 Seneca Street Gallery 1
1 of 17

12 Seneca Street

$8,000
12 Seneca Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Pool, Hot tub, and Refrigerator
Ultimate Relaxation
Short walk to ferry and ocean.
Discover the perfect getaway at 12 Seneca Street, surrounded by serenity and the sound of the waves. This stunning abode boasts a fabulous pool and a luxurious hot tub for ultimate relaxation. Guests rave about the expansive and well-maintained space, perfect for hosting larger groups comfortably. With a short stroll to the ferry and ocean, and an array of included beach gear, this home ensures memorable coastal adventures.
Recently updated units
105 Clipper Road Gallery 1
1 of 42

105 Clipper Road

$15,000
105 Clipper Way, Fire Island, NY 11770
(917) 734-6624
1 unit available
6 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Recently renovated, Stainless steel, Air conditioning + more
Recently updated units
39 Schooner Gallery 1
1 of 9

39 Schooner

$8,000
39 Schooner Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
(917) 734-6624
1 unit available
3 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Stainless steel, Fireplace, Range + more
Recently updated units
55 Ocean Road Gallery 1
1 of 14

55 Ocean Road

$7,500
55 Ocean Road, Fire Island, NY 11770
1 unit available
5 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Recently renovated, Stainless steel, Fireplace + more
Recently updated units
49 E Bayview Walk Gallery 1
1 of 11

49 E Bayview Walk

$25,000
49 Bay View Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 988-9059
1 unit available
1 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Pool, Bbq/grill, and Refrigerator
Recently updated units
33 Schooner Gallery 1
1 of 22

33 Schooner

$8,500
33 Schooner Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
(917) 734-6624
1 unit available
3 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Recently renovated, Hot tub, and Refrigerator
Beachside Luxury
Stunning renovations and unbeatable beach access
33 Schooner offers a newly renovated home just steps from the beach, perfect for seaside enthusiasts. The entertainment area with a bar and hot tub is ideal for hosting unforgettable gatherings, while the lush gardens and water views add a touch of tranquility. Residents praise the modernized interiors that maintain the home's charm.
Recently updated units
11 Bayview Walk Gallery 1
1 of 17

11 Bayview Walk

$10,000
11 Bayview Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 495-0568
1 unit available
3 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Recently renovated, Stainless steel, Air conditioning, Bbq/grill + more
Recently updated units
42 Evergreen Gallery 1
1 of 12

42 Evergreen

$35,000
42 Evergreen Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(917) 734-6624
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Pool, Playground, Basketball court, and Tennis court
Beachside Retreat
Prime location with beach and ferry access
42 Evergreen is a stunning Seaview home that brings natural light and comfort to its spacious interiors. Nestled just steps from the beach and ferry, residents enjoy easy access to seaside adventures and convenient travel options. The community exudes a peaceful, welcoming vibe that's perfect for those seeking relaxation and recreation with amenities like a pool, tennis, and basketball courts.
Recently updated units
35 Sloop Walk Gallery 1
1 of 22

35 Sloop Walk

$12,000
35 Sloop Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 495-0568
1 unit available
5 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Gym, Pool, Air conditioning + more
Recently updated units

Average rent in Fire Island, New York

The average rent for a 1 bedroom apartment in Fire Island is $25,000+, while the average rent for a 2 bedroom apartment is Ask. Rent rates updated 6 days ago
Studio
Ask
Prices trending down
1 Bed
$25,000+
Prices trending down
2 Beds
Ask
Prices trending down
3+ Beds
Ask
Prices trending down
* Averages are based on the rental prices of properties listed on Apartment List that don’t include fees

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

  • Bridgeport Apartments
  • Norwalk Apartments
  • Long Beach Apartments
  • Milford city Apartments
  • West Haven Apartments
  • Stratford Apartments
  • Glen Cove Apartments
  • Hampton Bays Apartments
  • Hicksville Apartments
  • Valley Stream Apartments
Best market deals
These units are the best deal in town.
5 Atlantic Avenue 3 Bed
3 Beds • 1 Bath
Base monthly rent
$2,500+
Available
Now
4 Surfview Walk 3 Bed
3 Beds • 2 Baths
Base monthly rent
$3,500+
Available
Now
760 Surf Road 3 Bed
3 Beds • 2 Baths
Base monthly rent
$4,500+
Available
Now
19 Champlain Street 4 Bed
4 Beds • 2 Baths
Base monthly rent
$4,500+
Available
Now
7 E End Walk 3 Bed
3 Beds • 2 Baths
Base monthly rent
$5,000+
Available
Now
Luxury apartments
Top units for an elevated lifestyle.
37 Kelp Walk 4 Bed
4 Beds • 2 Baths
Base monthly rent
$37,000+
Available
Now
9 Beachwold 3 Bed
3 Beds • 2 Baths
Base monthly rent
$35,000+
Available
Now
42 Evergreen 4 Bed
4 Beds • 2 Baths • 1042 sqft
Base monthly rent
$35,000+
Available
Now
30 Gale Walk 2 Bed
2 Beds • 1 Bath
Base monthly rent
$32,000+
Available
Now
49 E Bayview Walk 1 Bed
1 Bed • 1 Bath
Base monthly rent
$25,000+
Available
Now