Apartments for Rent in Fire Island, NY

57 rentals available

29 Superior Avenue
$24,000
29 Superior Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
3 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Air conditioning, and Refrigerator
Beachside Retreat
Prime beachside location with modern amenities.
29 Superior Avenue is a beach lover's paradise, situated just three houses from the coastline. Enjoy the stunning location with easy access to Fire Island's beautiful beaches and local attractions. The property features modern conveniences like air conditioning, in-unit laundry, and a garage, complemented by an open layout that lets in plenty of natural light.
Recently updated units
45 Evergreen Walk
$8,000
45 Evergreen Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, and Refrigerator
Beachside Retreat
Perfect getaway with ocean views and stunning gardens.
45 Evergreen Walk is a beautiful haven with proximity to the beach, providing an idyllic setting. Known for its immaculate gardens, this property ensures a serene and picturesque environment. Residents also enjoy the thoughtful amenities, such as an outdoor shower and beach essentials, making ocean excursions a breeze.
Recently updated units
39 Seneca Street
$12,000
39 Seneca Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
5 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, and Refrigerator
Oceanfront Living
Stunning ocean views from every window.
Experience true oceanfront living at 39 Seneca Street, Fire Island, with breathtaking ocean views from every window. The captivating open-layout design with cathedral ceilings creates an inviting atmosphere, enhanced by the home's stunning features like a sprawling deck and outdoor shower. Enjoy unparalleled access to the ocean just steps from your home.
Recently updated units
33 Sextant Walk
$4,000
33 Sextant Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
Studio
Amenities
Refrigerator
Beach Bliss
Quiet studio near beach with easy access.
33 Sextant Walk offers a tranquil beachside retreat on Fire Island, perfect for those who love the serene and peaceful atmosphere. It's just steps away from the sandy shores, providing effortless seaside access that residents adore. Enjoy thoughtful amenities like a beach umbrella, beach chairs, and an outdoor shower, as well as a small deck with washer and dryer for ultimate convenience.
Recently updated units
37 Kelp Walk
$37,000
37 Kelp Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Hardwood floors, Dishwasher, Recently renovated, and Tennis court
Serene Retreat
Charming and peaceful coastal sanctuary
Step into a delightful retreat just a block away from Bay Beach Park. Appreciate the newly renovated spaces with modern appliances and durable bamboo flooring throughout. Enjoy outdoor relaxation on the private back deck with a hot tub and grill, making it ideal for leisurely afternoons or entertaining guests.
Recently updated units
44 E Bayview Avenue
$18,000
44 Bayview Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
2 bed
Amenities
Patio / balcony and Refrigerator
Beach Proximity
Charming cottage steps from the ocean and bay.
Nestled steps from the Great South Bay and a short stroll to the ocean, this charming cottage is perfect for beach enthusiasts. Residents relish its proximity to local shops and restaurants, enhancing the vibrancy and convenience of their stay. Guests appreciate the clean and comfortable environment, consistently finding it well-maintained and cozy. Pet owners are warmly welcomed, allowing them to enjoy summer with their furry friends.
Recently updated units
790 Surf Road
$6,000
790 Surf Road, Fire Island, NY 11770
(917) 734-6624
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry and Dishwasher
Beachside Bliss
Prime Location for Seaside Living
Experience contemporary seaside living at its finest in this spacious and light-filled Fire Island home. Residents praise the prime location, offering effortless access to the beach. With amenities like an outdoor shower, in-unit laundry, and beach-ready gear, it ensures both comfort and convenience.
Recently updated units
12 Sea Breeze Walk
$5,900
12 Sea Breeze Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, and Refrigerator
Breathtaking Views
Idyllic island haven with exquisite bay views.
Experience an island retreat at 12 Sea Breeze Walk. This property offers stunning bay views and breathtaking sunsets, perfect for relaxing or hosting a gathering. Enjoy the convenience of in-home amenities like bicycles and paddleboards, enhancing your Fire Island experience.
Recently updated units
35 Beachwold Avenue
$6,000
35 Beachwold Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
5 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, and Refrigerator
Seaside Escape
Spacious retreat steps from Fire Island's serene beaches.
Experience the perfect beachside living at 35 Beachwold Avenue. The ample space in this charming property offers comfort for large families. Residents rave about the convenient guest cottage and the property's effortless proximity to the beach. Enjoy the serene and family-friendly atmosphere of the surrounding Seaview community.
Recently updated units
41 Atlantic Avenue
$8,000
41 Atlantic Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
Pool, Playground, Basketball court, and Tennis court
Beach Retreat
Beach proximity and vibrant village access.
41 Atlantic Avenue offers an enviable location, just a short stroll from the beach and near the bustling Village of Ocean Beach. Residents appreciate its fantastic amenities, including a pool and tennis courts. The property's wrap-around deck provides breathtaking views, perfect for unwinding after a day of leisure.
Recently updated units
32 Kelp Avenue
$8,000
32 Kelp Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
5 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Pool, Playground, Basketball court, and Tennis court
Family Haven
Ideal for families near kids' playground.
This property at 32 Kelp Avenue offers an inviting and bright environment, making it perfect for families. Its proximity to a children's playground ensures endless fun for young ones. Enjoy a refreshing outdoor shower after a day at the beach. The included beach amenities enhance every seaside experience.
Recently updated units
63 Thompson
$10,000
63 Thompson Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
2 bed
Beach Proximity
Prime beach access and stunning views await.
This charming home offers unmatched beach access with stunning views from a wrap-around deck. Located in the delightful Ocean Bay Park area, it's a peaceful retreat close to local shops and restaurants. The house is equipped with bikes and beach toys, perfect for those looking to enjoy seaside activities.
Recently updated units
30 Gale Walk
$32,000
30 Gale Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
2 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, and Dishwasher
Charming Getaway
Ideal for a Relaxing Beachside Retreat
Embrace a peaceful summer escape at this charming cottage. The private deck is perfect for enjoying meals under the stars, while in-unit laundry and a dishwasher add convenience to your stay. Reviews highlight the cozy interior, making it feel truly like a home away from home.
Recently updated units
49 Surf
$7,000
49 Surf Road, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
4 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, and Refrigerator
Spacious Retreat
Ideal for Beach Lovers and Large Groups
Residents adore 49 Surf for its spaciousness, ideal for large families or groups. This vacation home is a stone's throw away from the beach, making it a perfect seaside getaway. The well-equipped kitchen and dining areas are highly appreciated by guests, enhancing their vacation experience.
Recently updated units
9 Beachwold
$35,000
9 Beachwold Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
3 bed
Amenities
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Internet access, and Refrigerator
Seaside Retreat
Stunning wrap-around deck with scenic bay views.
9 Beachwold is a charming haven on Fire Island with a scenic wrap-around deck offering breathtaking sunrise and sunset views. Its excellent location close to the beach and local attractions enhances convenience and enjoyment. The spacious interior, complete with a well-stocked kitchen, promises a comfortable stay, while amenities like Direct TV, WiFi, and provided bicycles add to the overall experience.
Recently updated units
50 East End Walk
$30,000
50 East End Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770
(631) 661-5100
1 unit available
3 bed
Stellar Views
Breathtaking views of ocean and bay at Fire Island
Experience unparalleled views from the third-story crow's nest overlooking the Great South Bay and Atlantic Ocean. This cozy home boasts private balconies for each bedroom, offering tranquil ocean vistas. A recent renovation with high-end materials ensures a modern, comfortable living space in a remarkable location.
Recently updated units

Find an apartment for rent in Fire Island, NY

Searching for an apartment for rent in Fire Island, NY? Look no further! Apartment List will help you find a perfect apartment near you. There are 57 available rental units listed on Apartment List in Fire Island. Click on listings to see photos, floorplans, amenities, prices and availability, and much more!

The average rent in Fire Island is Ask for a studio, $25,000 for a one-bedroom apartment, and $18,000 for a two-bedroom apartment. If you are looking for a deal, keep an eye out for a red pulsing icon that indicates rent specials.

Tired of browsing? Take our personalized quiz. You’ll answer a couple of simple questions and we’ll put together a list of Fire Island apartments that are best for you. We’ll also factor in your commute, budget, and preferred amenities. Looking for a pet-friendly rental, or an apartment with in-unit washer and dryer? No problem, we’ll provide you with apartments that match that criteria.

You can trust Apartment List to help you find your next Fire Island, NY apartment rental! After all, everyone deserves a home they love.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

In Fire Island, the average rent is + for a studio, $25,000+ for a 1-bedroom, $18,000+ for a 2-bedroom, and + for a 3-bedroom.*

*Based on base prices that don’t include fees

You can use the pet-friendly filter to find apartments that allow pets.

The answer to this question depends on your household income and a couple of other factors. You can use our Rent Calculator to figure out how much you should spend on rent in Fire Island.

You can use the off-campus housing filters to find apartments near colleges located in or around Fire Island. Some of the colleges and universities in the area include Farmingdale State College, and Suffolk County Community College.

Apartments for Rent in Fire Island, NY

29 Superior Avenue

45 Evergreen Walk

39 Seneca Street

33 Sextant Walk

37 Kelp Walk

44 E Bayview Avenue

790 Surf Road

12 Sea Breeze Walk

35 Beachwold Avenue

41 Atlantic Avenue

32 Kelp Avenue

63 Thompson

30 Gale Walk

49 Surf

9 Beachwold

50 East End Walk

More Rental Options

Find an apartment for rent in Fire Island, NY

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How much is rent in Fire Island?

How can I find a pet-friendly apartment in Fire Island?

How much should I pay for rent in Fire Island?

How can I find off-campus housing in Fire Island?