/
/
/
luxury apartments
Last updated February 28 2021 at 6:10 PM

44 Luxury Apartments for rent in Fire Island, NY

Luxury apartments in Fire Island offer upscale living and the best amenities. Look for luxury apartments in city centers or popular neighborhoods with swimming pools, fitness... Read Guide >
1 Unit Available
790 Surf Road
790 Surf Road
Fire Island, NY
4 Bedrooms
$10,000
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Great Location, Very Spacious, And Full Of Light!
1 Unit Available
9 Beachwold
9 Beachwood Avenue
Fire Island, NY
3 Bedrooms
$35,000
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Charming 3 Bedroom, 1.5 Bath! Large Deck, Great Seaview Location! Close To Town! Has Direct TV and Wifi! Along With 4 Bikes For Your Use!
1 Unit Available
4 Superior Walk
4 Superior St
Fire Island, NY
3 Bedrooms
$16,000
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Single Family Home, Newly Renovated, Clean, Bright, And Open! Home Typically Rents By The Month, But Is Open To Two Week Rentals. Inquire Within On All Rental Rates!
1 Unit Available
60 Fairway
60 Fairway Avenue
Fire Island, NY
5 Bedrooms
$45,000
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Classic FI home! On a great block in Seaview, and only TWO houses from the beach with ocean views!
1 Unit Available
24 Huron
24 Huron Street
Fire Island, NY
4 Bedrooms
$25,000
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Seasonal Rental, Memorial Day- Labor Day $25,000. Steps From the Beach! Fabulous Location On A Great Block In Ocean Bay Park.
Results within 1 mile of Fire Island
1 Unit Available
20 Dune Lane
20 Dune Lane
West Hampton Dunes, NY
4 Bedrooms
$45,000
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
WHAT A SPOT!!!! #GOT KAYAK? #GOT CANOE? Smack Dab Bay Front w its Own Bay Beach + Terrific Sunsets..Great for Lots of Fun Stuff Incl Swimming.. Moor a Boat (Permit Required) ..Always a Little Easier than the Ocean which is Colder Longer in Spring +Can Be Wavy! The Ocean Access is Across the Street...Shabby Chic and Charm Galore this is a Renovated Home ......Available August and/or August thru October.....Thanks for Looking!
1 Unit Available
386 Dehnhoff
386 Dehnhoff Walk
Ocean Beach, NY | Ocean Beach
5 Bedrooms
$12,000
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Available To Rent Weekly for $12,000. Beautiful Home With 5 Bedrooms, 3 Bath, Outdoor Shower And A Pool! Home Includes 7 Bikes, Wagon, And 6 Beach Chairs For Your Use! Home Is Great For The Family Trip!
Results within 5 miles of Fire Island
1 Unit Available
9 Sea Breeze Avenue
9 Seabreeze Avenue
Westhampton, NY | Westhampton
3 Bedrooms
$28,000
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
1 Unit Available
126 The Helm
126 The Helm
East Islip, NY | East Islip
6 Bedrooms
$17,500
5000 sqft
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Waterfront Brick Mansion on shy 1 Acre w/180' of New Bulk-heading for your Fleet of deep water boats! Built like funds were endless this home has Radiant heat thru out under 1/4 sawn White Oak. Low maintenance Brick w/Synthetic Slate Roof. 6 Large Bedrooms, 1st Floor Junior Master. 2nd Floor Master w/ Nursery, 3 Walk in Closets, Marble Bath w/Tub and Shower. Chefs Kitchen w/ Viking appliances, 2 dishwashers, Wine station, Breakfast Room w/Private Views of Lagoon. Mud Room w/ 1/2 Bath & Back Stairway to Priv. Wing. Ent Foyer Flanked by Large Formal Dining Rm w/ Bay Views & Piano Room w/Tripple Herring bone Oak Flooring. Great Room, Billiard Room, Formal Living Rm. Plus 4 large Bedrooms. 2 Full baths & Laundry Rm. All on second floor Wing. 3rd Floor Attic Access Great Storage or additional Living Space. New LED Lighting inside & Out Heated IG Pool, Timeless Brick & Bluestone Patio, Barbecue Built into house w/ own Chimney. Gated, Guarded Association Community w/ Tennis Courts & B. Ball
1 Unit Available
9 Tanners Neck Lane
9 Tanners Neck Lane
Westhampton, NY | Westhampton
4 Bedrooms
$18,000
1378 sqft
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Looking for a home with a beachy atmosphere and bay views? You've found it! Enormous heated pool, tiki bar, multiple decks complete with rooftop deck overlooking the bay! Perfect for entertaining or relaxing in your personal island getaway. Master suite and guest bedrooms all on one level. Updated chefs' kitchen! Buy or rent but hurry this one won't last! Showings Wednesdays-Fridays 24 hr notice.
1 Unit Available
18 N Quarter Road
18 North Quarter Road
Westhampton, NY | Westhampton
4 Bedrooms
$39,000
2800 sqft
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Spend your summer in this private Westhampton oasis. Available for Aug-LD. Features four bedrooms 3 baths and a flowing floor plan. Situated on over an acre of private, scenic property with free form gunite pool and Har-Tru tennis court, don't miss this, summer awaits!
1 Unit Available
6 Bay Meadow Ln
6 Bay Meadow Lane
Westhampton, NY | Westhampton
6 Bedrooms
$65,000
3000 sqft
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Wonderful family retreat on two private acres in Westhampton South. Enjoy summer at its finest at this secluded yet central compound close to everything! This large, bright and comfortable home features six bedrooms (two on first level, four on second level), with open sun-filled living and gathering spaces. Enjoy the outdoors without leaving home with multiple decks, a grand porch, Har-Tru tennis court, a large heated pool, and open sunny lawns. Lovely, gracious, comfortable and fully equipped for summertime living! Won't last!
1 Unit Available
561 Dune Road
561 Dune Road
Westhampton, NY | Westhampton Beach
4 Bedrooms
$12,000
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Brand New Renovation On Dune Road In Westhampton ..Ocean Front! This Is 4 Bedrooms 3 Baths With Open Living Spaces...Views Galore...Multiple Decks! Just Bring Your Suit And Relax.. Beyond Mint Condition ....MIGHT be Available March 2021...MAYBE 1st 2 or 3 weeks in May . Rented Summer ....First 1, 2 or 3 Weeks Available August...Booking Fall 2021 and Winter and Summer 2022....THanks for Looking
1 Unit Available
493 Dune Road
493 Dune Road
Westhampton Beach, NY | Westhampton Beach
4 Bedrooms
$17,000
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Think Beach! Close To All In Whb..Shops, Movies, Houses Of Worship, Train, Theater And Ocean Front! New Home With Open Layout And Views Galore! Ocean Right Outside The Door! Gunite Heated Soaking Pool! 4 Brs 4.5 Baths, Two Laundries, Central Air! Booked thru March 2021...Available One or Two Weeks around 4th of July and One or Two Weeks Around Labor Day...Also Fall and Winter 2021....Booking Summer 2022 NOW!
1 Unit Available
782 Dune Road
782 Dune Road
West Hampton Dunes, NY
6 Bedrooms
$15,000
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Think Beach! Sprawling Beach House In Westhampton Dunes. Great Bedroom Separation. Open Layout. Directly Across The Street From The Ocean Access And Bay Front. Bay Is Great For Fishing, Clamming, Kayaking And Sunsets Galore! Views from Everywhere A Wonderful Way To Spend Some Time .Room for Everyone!... ...Rented Memorial to Labor Day 2021 Available Off Season...Pre and Post Season..Thanks for Looking!
1 Unit Available
49 Bridle Path
49 Bridle Path
Remsenburg-Speonk, NY | Remsenburg - Speonk
4 Bedrooms
$53,000
3587 sqft
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
The perfect place to work and play this summer! Enter from the covered front porch with porch swing to a grand foyer with sweeping staircase. Formal Living room and Dining room. Great room with fireplace and open concept to large Eat-in Kitchen with granite counter tops and stainless steel appliances. First floor MB Suite w/custom WIC. Master Bath feat. claw foot tub, skylight and walk-in shower. Additional 1st fl BR w/WIC and main floor full bath. Second Floor boasts balcony overlooking Great Room plus two additional bedrooms, full bath and office w/cathedral ceiling & skylight. Wood floors and LED high hats throughout. Ceiling fans. New furnishings. Full basement, partially finished w/ couch. This homes' Backyard Oasis feat. expansive covered porch w/lantern chandeliers, Heated inground pool, Har-tru tennis. Horseshoe court, Fire pit, Gazebo and Outdoor Shower. Bicycles avail. Gas grill. High Speed Internet avail. Detached 2 car garage. Available July $53k or Aug-LD for $60k.
1 Unit Available
71 Tanners Neck Lane
71 Tanners Neck Lane
Westhampton, NY | Westhampton
4 Bedrooms
$55,000
3795 sqft
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Summer Oasis with park-like setting. Inground Heated pool with child fence. Hot tub. Putting Green with three holes. Patio with bbq. House features expansive Eat-In Kitchen with granite counter tops. Great Rm w/ custom high ceiling, bar stool seating overlooking kitchen, fireplace and french doors to patio. Formal Living room w/fireplace. Formal Dining Room. Additional Office/Den offers additional space to relax or work. First floor Jr Master Bedroom w/sliders to back yard and private door to first floor full bath. First floor full bath also features ext. door for easy access from pool. Second floor Master Bedroom Suite with private balcony deck overlooking back yard. Master Bath features walk-in shower w/rain shower head and soaker tub. Two additional bedrooms and full bath on the second floor. Available August-LD, September 2021
Results within 10 miles of Fire Island
1 Unit Available
32 White Oak Lane
32 White Oak Lane
Westhampton Beach, NY | Westhampton Beach
4 Bedrooms
$60,000
2200 sqft
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Renovated, immaculate ranch in the Village of Westhampton Beach with open living room, dining area and kitchen. Primary bedroom suite with marble bath, large walk-in closet and sliding doors to private patio, junior guest suite with sliders to pool area, two additional guest bedrooms and bath. Outdoors is a lovely patio with heated gunite pool.
1 Unit Available
23 Bishop Avenue
23 Bishop Avenue
Westhampton, NY | Westhampton
4 Bedrooms
$60,000
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Spend August in this thoughtfully designed renovated home. Open concept floor plan - light & airy with meticulous attention to detail. Gourmet kitchen, dining area & living room with fireplace all opens to a spacious deck overlooking golf course. Heated gunite pool, 2 car garage and close to local shops & restaurants. Tenant responsible for beach access. Plan summer 2021 now!!
1 Unit Available
39 Cross Lane
39 Cross Lane
Westhampton Beach, NY | Westhampton Beach
4 Bedrooms
$75,000
950 sqft
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Location Location Location! Four bedroom, three bath Ranch on a Perfect Acre with Lush Green Grounds, Heated Gunite Pool and Pool House with Outdoor Shower. A Walk to Dune Road and Westhampton Village Shops. Ideal location in Estate Area, Perfect for Family Vacation.
1 Unit Available
58 South Road
58 South Road
Westhampton Beach, NY | Westhampton Beach
5 Bedrooms
$20,000
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Privately tucked away, but only 2 short blocks to the heart of the Village. Heated Gunite Pool and All Weather Tennis Court! 5 bedroom, 4-1/2 bath home includes state of the art kitchen, living room with fireplace, 2 guest wings, new bathrooms, finished basement with play room & bath, large screened porch with dining and living areas, huge terrace, central air and sprinkler system. Beautifully appointed home for the discerning summer renter. By appointment only. Sept is 9/1-30/ $20K; Sept-Oct 9/8 to 10/31 $35K. Oct. 10/1- 10/31 $20K Nov. 11/1-11/30 $15K
1 Unit Available
726 Ent Avenue
726 Ent Avenue
Westhampton, NY | Westhampton
3 Bedrooms
$12,000
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Private,Beautifully furnished 3 BR,2 newly tiled Full Bath Home w/Modern white kitchen,Living Room w/Vaulted ceilings and exposed beams, Wood Burning FP and Dining Area. Screened Sun Room overlooking hydrangea garden. 2 blocks to park Complete w/Community Tennis Court, In-Ground Pool, Basketball Court and Ball Field. 5 minute drive to town for restaurants,shopping, ice cream, Beach Bakery, Goldbergs Bagels and Much More! Reasonable, Private Westhampton Beach Retreat. Available Aug 1-LD and for extended season and off season as well.
1 Unit Available
19 Woodland Way
19 Woodland Way
Quogue, NY | Quogue
4 Bedrooms
$30,000
1400 sqft
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Quogue - Spacious Multi Level Contemporary Home Picturesque Lot. Entry Foyer To The Media Room With Remote Blinds And Projection Player, Main Living Area Offers Living Room W/Fireplace, Dining Area (Both With Sliders To Deck), Euro Kitchen, Laundry Room And Powder Room, Down 1/2 Level To Guest Bedroom, Bath Plus Game/Exercise Room, Up To Master Bedroom Suite And Up 1/2 Level From There To 2 Bdrms And Bath Plus A Loft With Fireplace. Heated Pool, Hot Tub, Outdoor Shower & Sport Court, Garage.
1 Unit Available
231 Dune Road
231 Dune Road
Westhampton Beach, NY | Westhampton Beach
Studio
Ask
1 Bedroom
$23,500
Last updated February 28 at 06:10 PM
Easy Beasy Summer! A Hotel Room at the Fabulous Bath and Tennis...1.5 Hrs from NYC and it has Ocean...Pool...Tennis....Gym and They Do It All! The Entire Complex is Social Distanced Regulated and I Think That will Still be in Effect Summer 2021. This Unit has Street Access to Make it Even Easier....They Have Towel Service at the Pool and Beach and Tennis Right Across the Street...Close to Westhampton Beach Main Street ...Shops...Houses of Worship and Restaurants...No Car Needed Here......Thanks for Looking....Need Notice to Show!
Find More Rentals By

Bedrooms

Fire Island 3 Bedroom Apartments
Find More Rentals in Nearby
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Frequently Asked Questions
How much is rent for a luxury apartment in Fire Island?
Rental prices for luxury apartments in Fire Island range from $10,000 to $45,000 per month.
How many luxury apartments are available for rent in Fire Island?
Currently, there are 5 luxury apartments available for rent in Fire Island.
What to keep in mind when looking for luxury apartments in Fire Island, NY

Luxury apartments in Fire Island offer upscale living and the best amenities. Look for luxury apartments in city centers or popular neighborhoods with swimming pools, fitness center, rooftop terraces, covered parking, and doormen.

Finding luxury apartments in Fire Island can be competitive, but there are usually several apartment complexes to choose from. Consider whether or not the amenities inside the apartment are as desirable as the shared amenities. The pool and tennis courts may look fantastic, but your kitchen could need an update. You should also consider the views and whether or not they fit your idea of luxurious living.

If cost is a factor, but you still want a luxury experience, try renting in a more residential neighborhood away from the action. Luxury apartments in Fire Island will be pricey no matter where you look, but some buildings will be less expensive than others