10 Safest Boston Neighborhoods for Renters in 2025 [Crime & Rent Data]

Boston remains one of the safest large U.S. cities, with the figures to back it up. The city experienced a 33.3% drop year-over-year drop in homicides (2024 vs. 2023), which highlights Boston's commitment to resident safety.

But stats only tell part of the story. Some neighborhoods just feel safer—whether that’s because of lower crime, a strong community presence, or the kind of streets where people actually stop to say hello. And if you're looking for a place to rent, safety matters as much as price, especially when you're locking into a lease.

This guide examines which Boston neighborhoods currently offer the best combination of safety and value. We examined crime data from the Boston Police Department, rent averages across the city, and factored in elements such as police presence and local community programs. Then we developed a simple “Safety-to-Rent” score to help you see how far your rent dollars go in terms of peace of mind. You’ll also find live rental listings for each neighborhood on Apartment List.

How We Identified Boston’s Safest Neighborhoods

To provide readers with accurate safety information by neighborhood, we used three pillars to create this guide: crime rates, rent data from Apartment List, Rent.com, Zumper, and the weighting formula. We targeted full-year 2024 crime figures from the Boston Police Department (BPD) compared to full-year 2023 figures.

Crime Data Sources and Time Frame

The crime data primary sources and time frame include:

• Boston Police Department Part One Crime Report (January to December 2023 vs January to December 2024)
  • The FBI classifies Part One crimes as serious offenses such as homicide, robbery, aggravated assault, burglary, theft, motor-vehicle theft, and arson.
• Crime Grade data by neighborhood/zipcode (as of August 2025)
• FBI UCR

How We Calculated Safety Scores

Each neighborhood was evaluated using the following weighted criteria to identify the safest areas for renters in Boston:

Factor Weights

• Crime rate (50%): Based on combined violent and property crime per 1,000 residents; lower rates received higher scores.
• Rent affordability (20%): Average one-bedroom rent compared to the city average ($3,786 in August 2025); neighborhoods below this threshold scored better.
• Amenities (20%): Composite score based on:
  • Parks per square mile (scored zero to 10).
  • Walk score (scored zero to 100).
  • Grocery stores within one mile (scored zero to 5).
• Commute (10%): Average peak-hour drive time to Downtown Boston; shorter commutes earned higher scores.

Each of the ten neighborhoods listed below ranked among the top performers across these combined factors, standing out for their mix of safety, accessibility, and renter-friendly features compared to the broader Boston metro area.

Crime-to-Rent Ratio Explained

Crime-to-rent ratio: the number of reported crimes per $1,000 of average annual rent. A lower ratio means more safety for every dollar spent on housing.

For example, if a Boston neighborhood reports 180 crimes per year and the average rent is $1,500 per month ($18,000 per year), the crime-to-rent ratio would be 10.0 crimes per $1,000 of rent.

This metric is particularly helpful for renters looking to reduce their costs. Rather than focusing solely on low rent or low crime, the ratio helps balance both, revealing which Boston neighborhoods offer the best overall value in terms of affordability and peace of mind.

Top 10 Safest Neighborhoods for Renters

Neighborhoods with a lower safety-to-rent value score are safer neighborhoods.

1. West Roxbury

One of Boston’s safest neighborhoods with notably low crime across all categories.

• Crime rate per 1,000: 16.67
• Average one-bedroom rent: $2,771
• Crime-to-rent ratio: 0.50

West Roxbury offers Bostonians suburban life within the city limits. It’s a quiet neighborhood with greenery, well-maintained single-family homes, and a strong community. Families, retirees, and longtime residents make up much of the population, and the area is known for its civic pride, solid public schools, and local businesses that stick around for decades.

West Roxbury has one of the lowest crime rates in the city, with just 16.67 per 1,000 residents. Per 1,000 residents, violent crimes account for 2.54, property crimes are 8.52, and other crimes total 5.2 (mostly vandalism).

Getting downtown takes about 30–40 minutes via the Commuter Rail’s Needham Line or several MBTA bus routes. Drivers appreciate the relatively low congestion and available parking. For anyone who values space, calm, and safety without moving to the suburbs, West Roxbury checks nearly every box.

Why It’s Great for Renters: Exceptional safety with the stability of a tight-knit, peaceful neighborhood.

2. Oak Square

A well-balanced neighborhood with moderate crime and fair rental rates.

• Crime rate per 1,000: 24.99
• Average one-bedroom rent: $2,400
• Crime-to-rent ratio: 0.87

Oak Square sits at the crossroads of Brighton’s residential quiet and Allston’s youthful energy. It’s a neighborhood that appeals to recent grads, young professionals, and longtime locals alike. While it’s not flashy, it’s practical—gyms, bars, restaurants, and groceries are all nearby, and the community feels lived-in rather than overly polished.

Crime sits at a moderate 24.99 per 1,000 residents. Violent crimes make up 4.18 per 1,000, property crimes 12.08 (with 8.74 being theft), and other crimes 8.73 (6.57 of which are vandalism).

Transit options include the 57, 64, and 501 buses, which make getting to downtown or Cambridge relatively straightforward, even without a train station. For renters who want something a little calmer than Allston but still energetic and one of the most affordable neighborhoods in Boston, Oak Square hits a sweet spot.

Why It’s Great for Renters: It’s an easy place to settle into city life without the stress or steep costs.

3. Mission Hills

Moderate crime rates with higher rent, nestled near medical and educational hubs.

• Crime rate per 1,000: 28.91
• Average one-bedroom rent: $2,800
• Crime-to-rent ratio: 0.86

Mission Hill is a compact neighborhood popular with students, hospital workers, and residents who want to stay close to the Longwood Medical Area. Its mix of triple-deckers, brownstones, and apartments gives it a unique urban texture.

The crime rate stands at 28.91 per 1,000. Violent crimes account for 5.11, property crimes for 12.56 (with 9.72 from theft), and 11.24 are other crimes (9.32 of which stem from vandalism).

With the Green Line E Branch, Roxbury Crossing on the Orange Line, and multiple bus routes, Mission Hill offers fast connections to downtown, JP, and Fenway. It’s a popular spot for renters who want proximity to institutions and transit without being in the city center.

4. Fenway-Kenmore

Crime fluctuates heavily by block, but this entertainment hub remains lively and walkable.

• Crime rate per 1,000: 29.40
• Average one-bedroom rent: $2,600
• Crime-to-rent ratio: 0.94

Fenway is known for its stadium, restaurants, bars, and museums—an active, vibrant part of the city that rarely sleeps. It’s a hub for students, professionals, and anyone looking to live close to action.

Crime data varies by micro-area, but on average, the neighborhood sees 29.40 crimes per 1,000 residents. Violent crime is 4.94, property crimes are 13.24, and other crimes are 11.22 (mostly vandalism at 9.23 per 1,000).

The B, C, and D branches of the Green Line run through the neighborhood, offering short rides into downtown. With everything from Fenway Park to the MFA nearby, it’s a strong pick for those who want entertainment and convenience.

Why It’s Great for Renters: For renters who want action, nightlife, and walkability, this is the spot.

5. Ashmont

Slightly higher crime, balanced by cultural richness and affordable rents.

• Crime rate per 1,000: 30.49
• Average one-bedroom rent: $2,600
• Crime-to-rent ratio: 0.98

Ashmont sits at the southern end of Dorchester and offers renters access to history, diversity, and growing local spots. It has a quieter side with large homes and a livelier section closer to the Red Line.

The crime rate is 30.49 per 1,000 residents. Violent crimes account for 6.76, property crimes 10.72 (7.76 of which are theft), and other crimes total 13.01, with 10.68 being vandalism.

Ashmont Station is a key Red Line terminal that gets commuters downtown in around 25 minutes. The area also serves as a hub for bus connections and has decent walkability for daily errands.

Why It’s Great for Renters: Affordable space and solid Red Line access make this a smart choice for value seekers.

6. Telegraph Hill

A scenic spot with balanced crime levels and attractive rents for South Boston.

• Crime rate per 1,000: 30.75
• Average one-bedroom rent: $2,390
• Crime-to-rent ratio: 1.07

Telegraph Hill is one of the more peaceful parts of Southie, known for Thomas Park, historic homes, and views of Dorchester Bay. It feels more residential than commercial, but still has access to the South Boston lifestyle.

Crime is 30.75 per 1,000. Violent crimes are 4.99, property crimes total 14.48 (11.81 being theft), and other crimes stand at 11.28, with vandalism making up 9.2.

The area lacks direct T access but is close enough to Red Line stops like Broadway or Andrew. It’s also served by MBTA buses and is walkable for errands, especially along East Broadway.

Why It’s Great for Renters: A great alternative to pricier South Boston addresses, without giving up charm.

7. Commonwealth

A bustling corridor with high crime but some of the city’s most affordable rents.

• Crime rate per 1,000: 31.14
• Average one-bedroom rent: $2,300
• Crime-to-rent ratio: 1.13

Commonwealth Avenue runs through one of Boston’s liveliest and most budget-friendly rental areas, especially popular with students and recent grads. The neighborhood is packed with takeout spots, dive bars, and late-night pizza joints, giving it a round-the-clock energy. It’s busy, convenient, and ideal for anyone who wants to stay close to campus or downtown without spending a fortune.

The crime rate is 31.14 per 1,000 residents. Violent crimes make up 5.06, property crimes total 14.07 (with 11.28 being theft), and other crimes reach 12 per 1,000 residents, 9.83 of which are vandalism.

The Green Line B branch runs right down Commonwealth Ave, making it easy to access BU, BC, and downtown Boston. While the neighborhood can feel hectic and crime is a concern, the low rent and unbeatable transit access keep it a popular choice.

Why It’s Great for Renters: It’s a top pick for budget-conscious renters who prioritize location and connection over quiet streets.

8. South End

Charming but costly, South End’s elegant homes come with a higher crime profile.

• Crime rate per 1,000: 33.02
• Average one-bedroom rent: $4,062
• Crime-to-rent ratio: 0.68

The South End is an elegant neighborhood defined by Victorian brownstones, art galleries, and some of the city's best dining. It’s upscale but creative, drawing professionals, artists, and young families alike. With well-kept parks and a vibrant local scene, it's one of Boston's most architecturally charming areas.

Crime is relatively high at 33.02 per 1,000. Violent crime stands at 6.49, property crime at 15.12 (11.94 from theft), and other crimes total 11.42 (9.23 of which are vandalism).

Orange and Silver Line access, along with walking distance to Back Bay and Copley, make commuting a breeze. While rents are high, the South End delivers on lifestyle and location.

Why It’s Great for Renters: Perfect for renters who want sophistication, character, and central access.

9. Highland Park

A cultural gem with elevated crime but deep community roots.

• Crime rate per 1,000: 39.20
• Average one-bedroom rent: $2,432
• Crime-to-rent ratio: 1.34

Highland Park is a mix of historic homes, artist spaces, and community gardens. It doesn’t feel manufactured—just lived-in, with long-time residents, newer renters, and a lot of neighborhood pride. The area has seen reinvestment over the years, but it still holds onto its roots.

The crime rate is higher than average at 39.20 per 1,000 residents. Violent crime accounts for 7.97, property crime totals 18.83 (with a significant 15.1 attributed to theft), and other crimes reach 12.39 (10.16 of which are vandalism).

Roxbury Crossing on the Orange Line and several MBTA bus routes connect Highland Park to the rest of the city. It’s an area where rent remains relatively affordable and where long-time residents take pride in their community’s resilience and evolution.

Why It’s Great for Renters: Great for those who value cultural vibrancy, history, and a neighborhood with real roots.

10. Back Bay

High-end living with high theft rates, where luxury and risk go hand in hand.

• Crime rate per 1,000: 49.65
• Average one-bedroom rent: $2,600
• Crime-to-rent ratio: 1.59

Back Bay is one of Boston’s most iconic neighborhoods—home to Newbury Street, Copley Square, and historic brownstones. It's a top destination for shopping, strolling along the Esplanade, or enjoying elegant cafés and nightlife.

The crime rate is 49.65 per 1,000, the highest on this list. That number is heavily skewed by property crime: 28.91 per 1,000 are property crimes, with 25.44 being theft. Violent crime is 8.04, and other crimes account for 12.70, including 10.15 vandalism.

The Green and Orange Lines, along with easy walking access to downtown, make this one of the best-connected parts of the city. While theft risk is real, many renters are drawn in by the location, energy, and historic feel.

Why It’s Great for Renters: For renters who want location, luxury, and walkability, even if safety comes at a price.

Safety-to-Rent Value Insights

Average Rents in the Ten Neighborhoods

Best Value Picks for Budget Renters

Renters seeking a safe neighborhood with lower average rent have several options. Currently, Boston’s average rent for a one-bedroom apartment is $3,484. Here are our top picks:

• West Roxbury - West Roxbury feels like a quiet suburb within the city, and has very low crime rates. The rent is higher, but many find the calm and safety worth it.
• Oak Square - Oak Square is more affordable and still has a good safety record. It’s a practical choice for young professionals who want easy access to transit and amenities.
• Mission Hill - Mission Hill’s rent is reasonable, and the community is tight-knit. Although crime rates are slightly higher, many renters appreciate being close to hospitals and schools.

There are other quick ways to save money on rent. If you can tolerate living with others, split a larger rental with roommates in a neighborhood that offers a lot of value for location and safety. For example, South End is a centrally located area, and the average rent for a two-bedroom apartment is $5,275. Split between two, that’s only $2,637.50, which is an average savings of 35% compared to the current one-bedroom apartment average rent of $4,062.

If roommates aren’t your thing, you can always opt for smaller rental units. In the same South End neighborhood, studios have an average rent of $3,238, which is 25% cheaper than a one-bedroom apartment.

Trends Driving Prices in Safer Areas

In recent years, the city of Boston and its police force have made significant investments in citywide safety. With a 35% drop in homicide rates and other decreases across the board, including a 7% decrease in robbery, a 6% decrease in residential burglary, and a 17% reduction in auto theft, it’s clear that many of the investments are working.

One of these initiatives is investment in Surveillance Technology. Between July 2023 and December 2024, the force spent a total of $1,227,674 on cameras, of which a total of $923,902 was for supporting cameras in Boston. These video management systems are used to reduce criminal activity, fear, and increase public safety, all while making it easier for the police force to do their jobs.

Declining crime in Boston neighborhoods typically increases demand, which in turn, has a rising effect on rent prices.

Pro Tips for Choosing the Right Boston Neighborhood

These tips can help you find a safe rental unit in Boston.

Vetting Safety Beyond Crime Stats

Data and crime statistics are just part of the story. Visit a neighborhood at different times of day to get a feel for the environment, vibe, and other community members before moving there. Chat up locals at local eateries, stores, or anyone relevant in the area. Ask about general safety for the neighborhood or any community policing efforts.

\ Community policing is a method where police officers work closely with residents to build trust, address safety concerns, and stay visible within the community. Neighborhoods with stronger ties to their officers often feel safer, which can result in lower crime rates.

\ You can also check the Boston Police Department’s incident map for block-by-block reports.

Balancing Commute, Lifestyle, and Security

Choosing where to live means weighing what matters most. You may be juggling a long commute with concerns about the safety of the streets at night, or whether you're near a park.

Here's how some neighborhoods compare:

• West Roxbury: Longest commute (~40 min via Commuter Rail), quiet and green, very low crime.
• Oak Square: Approximately 35 minutes via Green Line/Bus, affordable, decent safety, and a younger crowd.
• Mission Hill: Approximately 25–30 minutes via the Orange Line, with a strong community and a busier vibe, moderate crime rates.
• Fenway-Kenmore: Approximately a 20-minute walk or T ride, an active and dense area with higher property crime rates.
• Back Bay: Walkable to downtown, upscale, but has the highest crime and rent combo.

Leveraging Apartment List Tools for Real-Time Listings

Skip the revenge bedtime procrastination by scrolling through listings for hours until 2 a.m. Instead, use tools on Apartment List that narrow down your rental search by what matters most. In minutes, you can add a filter by budget, pet policy, transit access, and more.

Explore current West Roxbury listings on Apartment List.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Boston safer than other major East Coast cities?

According to Best Places, Boston has 27% fewer violent crimes and 23% fewer property crimes than Philadelphia. New York has lower crime rates, with 24% fewer violent crimes and 30% fewer property crimes than Boston.

Which safe neighborhoods are near MBTA subway lines?

Fenway–Kenmore (Green Line), Mission Hill (Orange Line), and Ashmont (Red Line) all offer direct subway access while maintaining relatively strong safety-to-rent value.

Do safer areas have lower renters’ insurance premiums?

Yes. Insurers often offer discounts in lower-crime ZIP codes; for example, renters in West Roxbury may pay up to 10% less per year.

Where can I find up-to-date crime reports?

The Boston Police Department publishes weekly incident maps and monthly Part One crime summaries on boston.gov.

Are there safe Boston neighborhoods with top-rated public schools?

West Roxbury and Ashmont both offer lower crime rates and access to respected public schools, making them popular with families.