100 Best Pet Friendly Apartments for Rent in Fire Island, NY - Page 4

Get our mobile app

Search apartments on the go

Company

About us
Careers
Company news
Product updates
Sunny.com (opens in new tab)
Support (opens in new tab)
FAQ (opens in new tab)
Sitemap

For renters

Renter Hub
Rate My Rent
Cost of Living Calculator
Rent Calculator
Renter Life blog
Rent Report

For property owners

A-List Portal (opens in new tab)
A-List Smart Platform (opens in new tab)
A-List Market (opens in new tab)
A-List Nurture (opens in new tab)
A-List Resident (opens in new tab)
Rental Management blog
Rental Data & Insights blog
Help Center (opens in new tab)

Privacy & policies

Privacy policy
Terms of use
Accessibility (opens in new tab)
Do not sell or share my info

(opens in new tab) (opens in new tab) (opens in new tab) (opens in new tab) (opens in new tab) (opens in new tab) (opens in new tab)

© 2026 Apartment List, Inc. All rights reserved.

Home Search Short list

Start your Fire Island, NY search

How many bedrooms do you need?

Home/
NY/
Fire Island/
Pet Friendly Apartments

Pet Friendly Apartments for Rent in Fire Island, NY

61 rentals available

1
2
3
4

Start your Fire Island search

How many bedrooms do you need?

Modern apartment interior

Get matched with your perfect apartment—faster

Smarter moves, less stress

Renter HubMoving, insurance, payments, and more
Rate My RentIs your rent a good deal?
Cost of Living CalculatorCalculate your city's cost of living
Rent CalculatorFind your rent sweet spot
Renter Life blogNavigating life as a renter
Rent ReportFind the best time to move

For property owners

A-List Portal (opens in new tab)
A-List Smart Platform (opens in new tab)
A-List Market (opens in new tab)
A-List Nurture (opens in new tab)
A-List Resident (opens in new tab)
Rental Management blog
Rental Data & Insights blog
Help Center (opens in new tab)

Home
Search
Short list

Home Search Short list

Home/
NY/
Fire Island/
Pet Friendly Apartments

Last updated August 19, 2026 at 2:31 AM EDT

More Rental Options

Amenities

Fire Island Luxury Apartments (23)

Cities

Patchogue Pet Friendly Apartments (8)
Ronkonkoma Pet Friendly Apartments (4)
Bay Shore Pet Friendly Apartments (9)
Centereach Pet Friendly Apartments (5)
Coram Pet Friendly Apartments (12)
Yaphank Pet Friendly Apartments (4)
Smithtown Pet Friendly Apartments (4)
Stony Brook Pet Friendly Apartments (4)
Mastic Beach Pet Friendly Apartments (7)
Port Jefferson Station Pet Friendly Apartments (5)

Counties

Suffolk County Apartments (1266)

Colleges

Suffolk County Community College (8)
Farmingdale State College (5)

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How much is rent for a pet-friendly apartment in Fire Island, NY?
Rental prices for pet-friendly apartments in Fire Island, NY range from $8,500 to $12,500 per month.
How many pet-friendly apartments are available for rent in Fire Island, NY?
Currently, there are 61 pet-friendly apartments available for rent in Fire Island, NY.
Are there any additional fees associated with renting a pet-friendly apartment in Fire Island, NY?
Yes, most landlords and property management companies in Fire Island, NY will ask for a refundable pet deposit. If there was no damage to the property caused by your pet, you should be able to recover the deposit at the end of your lease. Some rental properties in Fire Island, NY may also charge monthly pet rent.

Top cities

Bridgeport Apartments
Norwalk Apartments
Long Beach Apartments
Milford city Apartments
West Haven Apartments
Stratford Apartments
Hampton Bays Apartments
Hicksville Apartments
Westport Apartments
Glen Cove Apartments

Listings

38 Homesite Avenue Gallery 1

1 of 27

38 Homesite Avenue (opens in new tab)

38 Homesite Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770

$7,000/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

4 bed

6 Champlain Gallery 1

49 Surf Gallery 1

170 Clipper Gallery 1

1 of 11

35 Beachwold Avenue Gallery 1

12 Sea Breeze Walk Gallery 1

63 Thompson Gallery 1

1 of 16

790 Surf Road Gallery 1

1 of 8

Amenities

In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Hardwood floors, Dishwasher, Recently renovated, Stainless steel + more

1 of 15

6 Champlain (opens in new tab)

6 Champlain Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770

$5,000/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

5 bed

Amenities

Patio / balcony and Game room

18 Erie Street Gallery 1

1 of 17

18 Erie Street (opens in new tab)

18 Erie Street, Fire Island, NY 11770

$5,300/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

2 bed

Amenities

In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Hot tub, Bbq/grill, and Refrigerator

1 of 12

49 Surf (opens in new tab)

49 Surf Road, Fire Island, NY 11770

$7,000/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

4 bed

Amenities

In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Fireplace, and Refrigerator

170 Clipper (opens in new tab)

170 Clipper Way, Fire Island, NY 11770

$7,500/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

4 bed

Amenities

In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Air conditioning, Fireplace, and Refrigerator

1 of 13

35 Beachwold Avenue (opens in new tab)

35 Beachwold Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770

$6,000/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

5 bed

Amenities

In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Fireplace, and Refrigerator

1 of 13

12 Sea Breeze Walk (opens in new tab)

12 Sea Breeze Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770

$5,900/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

4 bed

Amenities

In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Fireplace, and Refrigerator

320 Frigate Rdw Gallery 1

1 of 16

320 Frigate Rdw (opens in new tab)

320 Frigate Rdw, Fire Island, NY 11770

$7,000/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

4 bed

Amenities

In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Air conditioning, Accessible, and Refrigerator

9 Beachwold Gallery 1

1 of 12

9 Beachwold (opens in new tab)

9 Beachwold Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770

$35,000/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

3 bed

Amenities

In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Internet access, and Refrigerator

1005 Surf View Gallery 1

1 of 43

1005 Surf View (opens in new tab)

1005 Surf View Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770

$15,000/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

4 bed

Amenities

In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Oven, and Refrigerator

760 Surf Road Gallery 1

1 of 16

760 Surf Road (opens in new tab)

760 Surf Road, Fire Island, NY 11770

$4,500/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

3 bed

Amenities

In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Internet access, and Refrigerator

63 Thompson (opens in new tab)

63 Thompson Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770

$10,000/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

2 bed

790 Surf Road (opens in new tab)

790 Surf Road, Fire Island, NY 11770

$6,000/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

4 bed

Amenities

In unit laundry and Dishwasher