Last updated April 28 2024 at 8:59 AM

Middle Island, NY
23 Condos for Rent

Prices shown are base rent prices and may not include non-optional fees and utilities.
Finding condos for rent in Middle Island is almost no different than renting an apartment in a big complex. The real difference is the ownership. Condos are owned by indivi... Read Guide >
1 of 7
Results within 1 mile of Middle Island
1 of 7
Results within 5 miles of Middle Island
1 of 9
1 of 7
1 of 7
1 of 22
Results within 10 miles of Middle Island
1 of 22
1 of 5
1 of 7
1 of 7
1 of 7
1 of 7
1 of 7
1 of 7
1 of 7
1 of 7
1 of 7
1 of 17
1 of 32
1 of 14
1 of 10
1 of 5
1 of 7
City Guide for Middle Island, NY

Ancient history: Even if you're not a caveman -- and let's hope you're not -- you can still walk the same ground the earliest ancestors walked in Middle Island. An ancient glacier hole formed during the Ice Age created the local Artist Lake, a freshwater lake stocked with all kinds of species of fish. So even if you don't want to live like you're in the Ice Age, you can still catch your own dinner just like they did.

Whether geographical history grabs you or not, this quaint little dot on the map is steeped in tons of tradition and pioneer history. Middle Island is a neat little burg located in Suffolk County, the fourth most populated county in the state of New York. This landlocked piece of real estate claims an 8.3-square-mile chunk of geographic landscape, albeit as a census-designated place (CDP) and not a bona fide, incorporated city, town or village. This little landscape makes up the entire central and eastern portion of "Long Island," a suburban stretch of seacoast-lined beauty that's just a hop, skip and a jump from New York City. See more

What to keep in mind when looking for condos in Middle Island, NY

Finding condos for rent in Middle Island is almost no different than renting an apartment in a big complex. The real difference is the ownership. Condos are owned by individuals within the same building. However, apartments in a large complex are owned by a single landlord or property management group.

Sometimes the price of condos in Middle Island may prove cheaper. The owners are often moving onto a new home or leaving the city and just need someone to cover the costs. Apartment complexes are designed to deal with tenant issues, make repairs, and care for the property. Condo owners will still deal with repairs and upkeep but may need more time to address a problem, especially if they don’t live nearby. However, condo owners have a more vested interest in the property and keeping their tenants happy to reduce turnover.

Choose the best condos for rent in Middle Island that meet your wishlist for budget, amenities, and layout. You probably won’t notice the difference between the condos and apartments you tour.