Check out 127 verified apartments for rent in Shelter Island, NY. Prices shown are base rent prices and may not include non-optional fees and utilities.
1 of 35
15 Montclair Avenue
15 Montclair Avenue, Shelter Island Heights NY 11964 (631) 288-6900
$75,000
1 unit available
6 bed
Patio / balcony, New construction, Pool, Hot tub, and Sauna
Results within 5 miles of Shelter Island
1 of 14
24 Forest Crossing
24 Forest Crossing, Bridgehampton NY 11962 (917) 972-5501
$42,500
1 unit available
3 bed
On-site laundry, Patio / balcony, Hardwood floors, Dishwasher, Parking, Recently renovated + more
1 of 20
695 Rogers Road
695 Rogers Road, Southold NY 11971
$15,000
1 unit available
5 bed
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Fireplace, Oven, and Refrigerator
1 of 19
165 Sterling Street
165 Sterling Street, Greenport NY 11944 (631) 765-5815
$12,000
1 unit available
3 bed
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Oven, and Refrigerator
1 of 25
1 of 17
15 Mount Misery Drive
15 Mount Misery Drive, Noyack NY 11963 (631) 881-5160
$13,000
1 unit available
3 bed
Patio / balcony, Pet friendly, Fire pit, and Bbq/grill
1 of 20
1 of 2
42 Lincoln Street
42 Lincoln Street, Sag Harbor NY 11963
$25,000
1 unit available
3 bed
Dishwasher and Refrigerator
1 of 19
1100 Pine Avenue
1100 Pine Avenue, Southold NY 11971 (631) 765-5815
$28,000
1 unit available
3 bed
Bbq/grill
1 of 7
20 Terry Drive
20 Terry Drive, Sag Harbor NY 11963
$20,000
1 unit available
3 bed
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, and Microwave
1 of 31
360 Bayview Drive
360 Bayview Drive, East Marion NY 11939 (631) 673-3700
$15,000
1 unit available
4 bed
New construction
1 of 23
1 of 21
1 of 19
412 Front Street
412 Front Street, Greenport NY 11944
$3,200
1 unit available
1 bed • 2 bed
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Recently renovated, Air conditioning, Microwave + more
1 of 9
1 of 20
35 Stirling Cove
35 Stirling Cove, Greenport NY 11944 (917) 445-1977
$12,000
1 unit available
2 bed
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Pool, Tennis court, and Microwave
1 of 10
21 Peconic AVenue
21 Peconic Avenue, Shelter Island Heights NY 11965
$50,000
1 unit available
3 bed
Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Microwave, and Refrigerator
1 of 11
470 Goose Creek Lane
470 Goose Creek Lane, Southold NY 11971 (631) 765-5815
$30,000
1 unit available
3 bed
In unit laundry, Dishwasher, Pool, Oven, and Refrigerator
1 of 19
1 of 12
160 5th Street
160 5th Street, Greenport NY 11944
$6,000
1 unit available
2 bed
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Recently renovated, Pool, and Tennis court
1 of 27
1935 Old Orchard Road
1935 Old Orchard Road, East Marion NY 11939
$6,000
1 unit available
2 bed
Patio / balcony, Pool, and Bbq/grill
1 of 24
295 Rabbit Lane
295 Rabbit Lane, East Marion NY 11939 (631) 288-6900
$75,000
1 unit available
3 bed
In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Dishwasher, Fireplace, Microwave, and Refrigerator
1 of 18
2395 Bay Avenue
2395 Bay Avenue, East Marion NY 11939 (631) 288-6900
$15,000
1 unit available
3 bed
Fire pit
1 of 9
700 Gin Lane
700 Gin Lane, Southold NY 11971 (631) 673-3700
$50,000
1 unit available
4 bed
Patio / balcony, New construction, Pool, and Fireplace
Find More Rentals in Nearby
Cities
- Sag Harbor, NY Apartments (3)
- Greenport, NY Apartments (10)
- Greenport West, NY Apartments (12)
- East Marion, NY Apartments (10)
- Noyack, NY Apartments (7)
- Orient, NY Apartments (5)
- Northwest Harbor, NY Apartments (8)
- Southold, NY Apartments (36)
- Bridgehampton, NY Apartments (3)
- East Hampton North, NY Apartments (5)
- North Sea, NY Apartments (6)
- Springs, NY Apartments (5)
- Cutchogue, NY Apartments (9)
- Shinnecock Hills, NY Apartments (3)
- Mattituck, NY Apartments (10)
- Saybrook Manor, CT Apartments (3)
Zip Codes
Counties
Find More Rentals Near
Airports
Medical Facilities
Find an apartment for rent in Shelter Island, NY
Searching for an apartment for rent in Shelter Island, NY? Look no further! Apartment List will help you find a perfect apartment near you. There are 127 available rental units listed on Apartment List in Shelter Island. Click on listings to see photos, floorplans, amenities, prices and availability, and much more!
Tired of browsing? Take our personalized quiz. You’ll answer a couple of simple questions and we’ll put together a list of Shelter Island apartments that are best for you. We’ll also factor in your commute, budget, and preferred amenities. Looking for a pet-friendly rental, or an apartment with in-unit washer and dryer? No problem, we’ll provide you with apartments that match that criteria.
You can trust Apartment List to help you find your next Shelter Island, NY apartment rental! After all, everyone deserves a home they love.
Frequently Asked Questions
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
How can I find a pet-friendly apartment in Shelter Island?
You can use the pet-friendly filter to find apartments that allow pets.
How much should I pay for rent in Shelter Island?
The answer to this question depends on your household income and a couple of other factors. You can use our Rent Calculator to figure out how much you should spend on rent in Shelter Island.
How can I find off-campus housing in Shelter Island?
You can use the off-campus housing filters to find apartments near colleges located in or around Shelter Island. Some of the colleges and universities in the area include Yale University, Albertus Magnus College, Southern Connecticut State University, University of New Haven, and United States Coast Guard Academy.