apartments with garage

Last updated May 22 at 8:47 PM

229 Apartments for rent in Fire Island, NY with Garages

Fire Island apartments with garages are sometimes more expensive than other options. However, they may make more financial sense in the long run. Weather, break-ins, and... Read Guide >

1 of 36

1 Unit Available

626 Shore Walk

626 Shore Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770

3 Bedrooms

Ask

4 Bedrooms

$25,000

Luxury Summer Rental !! ,This inviting, Impeccably Finished and appointed 4 Bedroom 4 Full bath Home with a pool in Desirable Fire Island Pines Comes With All The Delights . This Ultra Modern Glass Style Beach Home Features The Downstairs with Open Living Space , Living room w/fireplace , Stylish High End Kitchen, Dining room with Amazing Skylight ,1 Bedroom Suite , Full Bath w/tub, Bedroom and another Private Bedroom Suite. Access to the Decks And Pool Area from Every Location. The Staircase Takes You Up To The Private Bedroom Suite w/fireplace and Views that you may never want to leave. Outdoors Relax By The Pool ,Enjoy the Barbeque and Get cozy in the Private Cabana area with your Favorite Music.

1 of 13

1 Unit Available

12 Sea Breeze Walk

12 Sea Breeze Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770

4 Bedrooms

$6,545

Truly an oasis, this stunning Atlantique home features views of the Bay with spectacular sunsets and a panoramic view of Fire Island. It offers 4 Bedrooms and 2 Full Baths and a spacious Open Concept Living Room, Dining Room and Kitchen leading to a large wrap around deck. Conveniently located. Easily accessible from the ferry. During your stay you can enjoy the many amenities of the home including 4 bicycles, 4 Beach Chairs with Umbrella and a Paddle Board for the more adventurous. Everything you need for the perfect Island getaway is right here.

1 of 20

1 Unit Available

32 Kelp Avenue

32 Kelp Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770

5 Bedrooms

$5,900

Very Bright & Airy Cozy Home Located Very Close To Children's Playground- Perfect For Families. 5 Bedrooms Sleeps 10 And 2 Full Baths Plus An Outside Shower! This Home Also Includes 4 Bikes, A Wagon, A Beach Umbrella And 8 Beach Chairs.

1 of 21

1 Unit Available

50 East End Walk

50 East End Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770

3 Bedrooms

$30,000

Ocean Front, Fabulous Ocean and Bay Views! Extremely Cozy Home In The Most Special Location

1 of 1

1 Unit Available

180 Clipper Road

180 Clipper Way, Fire Island, NY 11770

3 Bedrooms

$6,000

Only 5 Houses From The Beach! Light and Airy With Large Picture Windows And Beautiful Outdoor Entertaining Areas!

1 of 18

1 Unit Available

42 Evergreen

42 Evergreen Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770

4 Bedrooms

$28,000

Lovely four bedroom, two bathroom Seaview home in GREAT location offers a ton of light and plenty of room for ALL! Close to the beach and ferry.

1 of 18

1 Unit Available

33 Schooner

33 Schooner Walk, Fire Island, NY 11770

3 Bedrooms

$7,500

Beautiful, newly renovated home just steps from beach in lovely Summer Club. Great entertainment area with bar and hot tub as well as gorgeous gardens, and water views!!!

1 of 15

1 Unit Available

63 Thompson

63 Thompson Ave, Fire Island, NY 11770

2 Bedrooms

$10,000

Charming 2 Bedroom, 1 Bath, Very Close To Beach! Great Ocean Bay Park Location!

1 of 20

1 Unit Available

4 Superior Walk

4 Superior St, Fire Island, NY 11770

3 Bedrooms

$16,000

Single Family Home, Newly Renovated, Clean, Bright, And Open! Home Typically Rents By The Month, But Is Open To Two Week Rentals. Inquire Within On All Rental Rates!

1 of 12

1 Unit Available

9 Beachwold

9 Beachwood Avenue, Fire Island, NY 11770

3 Bedrooms

$35,000

Charming 3 Bedroom, 1.5 Bath! Large Deck, Great Seaview Location! Close To Town! Has Direct TV and Wifi! Along With 4 Bikes For Your Use!

Results within 1 mile of Fire Island

1 of 16

1 Unit Available

20 Dune Lane

20 Dune Road, West Hampton Dunes, NY 11978

4 Bedrooms

$72,000

WHAT A SPOT!!!! #GOT KAYAK? #GOT CANOE? Smack Dab Bay Front w its Own Bay Beach + Terrific Sunsets..Great for Lots of Fun Stuff Incl Swimming.. Moor a Boat (Permit Required) ..Always a Little Easier than the Ocean which is Colder Longer in Spring +Can Be Wavy! The Ocean Access is Across the Street...Shabby Chic and Charm Galore this is a Renovated Home ......Available Summer 2022 Pre and Post Season too!..Thanks for Looking!

1 of 8

1 Unit Available

363 Dehnhoff Walk

363 Dehnhoff Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

Ocean Beach

3 Bedrooms

$5,000

Fabulous Home Close to the Beach With 3 Bedrooms Includes an Alcove With a Single Bed, 2 Full Baths. New Roof & Washing Machine. This House Enjoys an Excellent Location South of Midway on a Block Without Beach Access So There is Less "Traffic" on Weekends. Includes 4 Bikes, Beach Chairs, Beach Umbrella & Wagon.

1 of 16

1 Unit Available

603 Bayberry Walk

603 Bayberry Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

Ocean Beach

4 Bedrooms

$9,500

This stunning home was beautifully renovated, featuring 4 bedrooms, two baths and offers ample space to accommodate all. Fabulous deck with outdoor dining, close to both the beach and town!

1 of 18

1 Unit Available

748 Ocean Breeze Walk

748 Ocean Breeze Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

Ocean Beach

4 Bedrooms

$15,000

Great Rental for a Large Family. Features a Heated Swimming Pool and Sectional Outdoor Seating. Upstairs has a Spacious Master En Suite with a Balcony.

1 of 17

1 Unit Available

192 Cottage Walk

192 Cottage Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

Ocean Beach

3 Bedrooms

$8,500

This Charming 3 Bedroom Home Has Been Recently Renovated From Top To Bottom. Enjoy Open Concept Great Room With New Kitchen That Opens Up To A New Deck. Also Enjoy A Second Story Deck. This Home Also Includes An Outside Shower, 8 Beach Chairs, 5 Bikes + A Trike, A Wagon And A Beach Umbrella.

1 of 12

1 Unit Available

674 Ocean Breeze

674 Ocean Breeze Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

Ocean Beach

5 Bedrooms

$12,000

Stunning Contemporary home that is ALWAYS being improved upon! Large pool. Close to the beach! Book your Summer rental for 2022

1 of 14

1 Unit Available

345 Dehnhoff Walk

345 Dehnhoff Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

Ocean Beach

5 Bedrooms

$13,000

Lovely, NEW, five bedroom, three full bathroom home with pool. Close to the beach and town! Book your Summer 2022 rental fast!

1 of 10

1 Unit Available

350 Dehnhoff Walk

350 Dehnhoff Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

Ocean Beach

4 Bedrooms

$6,000

Centrally Located! 4 Bedrooms, 2.5 Bath, Bright And Sunny! Home Provides Beach Chairs, And Has An Outdoor Shower!

1 of 22

1 Unit Available

343 Dehnhoff

343 Dehnhoff Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

Ocean Beach

3 Bedrooms

Ask

4 Bedrooms

$8,500

Beautifully Finished, New Hot Tub, and Perfect Location To Vacation!

1 of 13

1 Unit Available

102 Marine Walk

102 Marine Walk, Saltaire, NY 11770

Saltaire

4 Bedrooms

$6,000

Immaculate Lovely Cottage! Located Close To Bay Beach, Ferry, And Playground!

1 of 11

1 Unit Available

736 Ocean Breeze

736 Ocean Breeze Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

Ocean Beach

4 Bedrooms

$6,000

Beautiful, Spacious, Cathedral Ceiling - Very Pretty! Great Block And Close To Beach!

1 of 14

1 Unit Available

738 Ocean Breeze

738 Ocean Breeze Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

Ocean Beach

5 Bedrooms

$9,000

Beautifully Updated Beach House! With 5 Bedrooms, 2 Full Baths, and Sun Flooded Hi-Ceilinged Contemporary Home!

1 of 15

1 Unit Available

672 Ocean Breeze

672 Ocean Breeze Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

Ocean Beach

4 Bedrooms

$7,500

Beautiful Beach House! Located Close To The Beach. 4 Bedrooms, 2 Bath!

1 of 14

1 Unit Available

337 Dehnhoff Walk

337 Dehnhoff Walk, Ocean Beach, NY 11770

Ocean Beach

4 Bedrooms

$5,500

Booking Summer Rentals! Cozy Ocean Beach House For Rent With Private Deck, 4 Bedrooms, 2 Full Baths.

Find More Rentals By

Bedrooms

Amenities

Find More Rentals in Nearby

Cities

Zip Codes

Counties

Suffolk County Apartments (497)

Colleges

Farmingdale State College (6)

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

How much is rent for an apartment with a garage in Fire Island?

Rental prices for apartments with garages in Fire Island range from $5,900 to $35,000 per month.

How many apartments with garages are available for rent in Fire Island?

Currently, there are 10 apartments with garages available for rent in Fire Island.

What to keep in mind when looking for apartments with garages in Fire Island, NY

Fire Island apartments with garages are sometimes more expensive than other options. However, they may make more financial sense in the long run.

Weather, break-ins, and daily struggles to find a space can take a toll financially and physically. Remember that even cities in mild climates experience issues like salt air, tornadoes, hail, falling branches from storms, and other issues.

It’s also possible to score an auto insurance reduction if you park in a garage. Ask your insurance provider about any deals or discounts that could trim money off the cost of your monthly bill.

Before signing a lease, ask the landlord or property manager about any restrictions on garage use. It’s important to know if there are enough spaces for tenants and visitors and what happens if the garage is full. If you’re moving into an apartment inside a home, ask about any conditions on its use and if storage is allowed.