/
/
/
apartments with garage
Last updated April 21 at 9:25 AM

328 Apartments for rent in Fire Island, NY with Garages

Fire Island apartments with garages are sometimes more expensive than other options. However, they may make more financial sense in the long run. Weather, break-ins, and... Read Guide >
1 Unit Available
50 East End Walk
50 East End Walk
Fire Island, NY
3 Bedrooms
$30,000
Last updated April 21 at 8:15 AM
Ocean Front, Fabulous Ocean and Bay Views! Extremely Cozy Home In The Most Special Location
1 Unit Available
180 Clipper Road
180 Clipper Way
Fire Island, NY
3 Bedrooms
$6,000
Last updated April 21 at 8:15 AM
Only 5 Houses From The Beach! Light and Airy With Large Picture Windows And Beautiful Outdoor Entertaining Areas!
1 Unit Available
4 Superior Walk
4 Superior St
Fire Island, NY
3 Bedrooms
$16,000
Last updated April 21 at 8:15 AM
Single Family Home, Newly Renovated, Clean, Bright, And Open! Home Typically Rents By The Month, But Is Open To Two Week Rentals. Inquire Within On All Rental Rates!
1 Unit Available
9 Beachwold
9 Beachwood Avenue
Fire Island, NY
3 Bedrooms
$35,000
Last updated April 21 at 8:15 AM
Charming 3 Bedroom, 1.5 Bath! Large Deck, Great Seaview Location! Close To Town! Has Direct TV and Wifi! Along With 4 Bikes For Your Use!
Results within 1 mile of Fire Island
1 Unit Available
97 Bungalow
97 Bungalow Walk
Ocean Beach, NY | Ocean Beach
3 Bedrooms
$4,500
Last updated April 21 at 8:15 AM
A Charming Cottage On Bungalow Walk! Clean And Steps From the Ocean!
1 Unit Available
738 Ocean Breeze
738 Ocean Breeze Walk
Ocean Beach, NY | Ocean Beach
5 Bedrooms
$9,000
Last updated April 21 at 8:15 AM
Beautifully Updated Beach House! With 5 Bedrooms, 2 Full Baths, and Sun Flooded Hi-Ceilinged Contemporary Home!
1 Unit Available
337 Dehnhoff Walk
337 Dehnhoff Walk
Ocean Beach, NY | Ocean Beach
4 Bedrooms
$4,500
Last updated April 21 at 8:15 AM
Booking Summer Rentals! Cozy Ocean Beach House For Rent With Private Deck, 4 Bedrooms, 2 Full Baths. Call Lisa For Availability!
1 Unit Available
649 Ocean Breeze
649 Ocean Breeze Walk
Ocean Beach, NY | Ocean Beach
4 Bedrooms
$5,130
Last updated April 21 at 8:15 AM
Charming Spacious 2 Story Beach Rental! 4 Bedrooms, 2.5 Bath Centrally Located In Ocean Beach!
Results within 5 miles of Fire Island
1 Unit Available
63 Thompson
63 Thompson Drive
West Bay Shore, NY | West Bay Shore
2 Bedrooms
$10,000
Last updated April 21 at 8:15 AM
Charming 2 Bedroom, 1 Bath, Very Close To Beach! Great Ocean Bay Park Location!
1 Unit Available
50 S Phillips Avenue
50 South Phillips Avenue
Remsenburg-Speonk, NY | Remsenburg - Speonk
4 Bedrooms
$19,500
Last updated April 21 at 8:15 AM
Beautiful Colonial Cottage in Remsenburg Hamlet - 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths; spacious 1st floor master with full bath. Detached 2 car garage, huge backyard with inground pool. Close to Southampton Town Beaches, About a 5 minute drive to town of Westhampton Beach. Rental available for the months of May, June, July or August and Off season rental.
1 Unit Available
49 Bridle Path
49 Bridle Path
Remsenburg-Speonk, NY | Remsenburg - Speonk
4 Bedrooms
$53,000
3587 sqft
Last updated April 21 at 8:15 AM
The perfect place to work and play this summer! Enter from the covered front porch with porch swing to a grand foyer with sweeping staircase. Formal LR and DR. Great room with fireplace and open concept to large EIK with granite counter tops and stainless steel appliances. First floor MB Suite w/custom WIC. Master BA feat. claw foot tub, skylight and walk-in shower. Additional 1st fl BR w/WIC and main floor full bath. Second Floor boasts balcony overlooking Great Room plus two additional bedrooms, full bath and office w/cathedral ceiling & skylight. Wood floors and LED high hats throughout. Ceiling fans. New furnishings. This homes' Backyard Oasis feat. exp. covered porch w/lantern chandeliers, Heated IG pool, Har-tru tennis. Horseshoe court, Fire pit, Gazebo and Outdoor Shower. Access to WHB Village Beaches w/paid permit. Bicycles avail. Gas grill. High Speed Internet avail. Detached 2 car garage. Available July $53k or Aug-LD for $60k.
1 Unit Available
69 Case Avenue
69 Case Avenue
East Patchogue, NY | East Patchogue
2 Bedrooms
$2,500
1294 sqft
Last updated April 20 at 4:31 AM
Great condition. Private home with all Large size rooms. Detached garage. Walking distance to the beach, village and shopping. Credit and background check required . Available May 1st.
Results within 10 miles of Fire Island
Verified
2 Units Available
The Reserve at the Boulevard
1 Reserve Drive
Yaphank, NY | Yaphank
1 Bedroom
Ask
2 Bedrooms
$2,724
1310 sqft
Last updated April 21 at 9:25 AM
1-2 bedroom apartments with lush organic aesthetic. In-unit laundry and patio or balcony vistas. Maintenance on call 24/7. Parking, gym and pool available on site. Pets welcome.
Verified
110 Units Available
Alston Station Square
1000 Mill Rd
Ronkonkoma, NY | Centereach
Studio
Ask
1 Bedroom
$2,442
733 sqft
2 Bedrooms
$3,026
1115 sqft
Last updated April 21 at 3:37 AM
Welcome to Alston, a collection of stylish residences in the new heart of town, Station Square. Alston is six luxury residential buildings, each with its own distinctive character. Six buildings with a singular purpose: to deliver a daily experience of the best of Long Island, in a community you'll be proud to call home. Brand new apartment homes now leasing.
Verified
1 Unit Available
New Village at Patchogue
1 Village Green
East Patchogue, NY | Patchogue
1 Bedroom
$2,803
742 sqft
2 Bedrooms
Ask
3 Bedrooms
Ask
Last updated April 21 at 3:37 AM
Modern layouts featuring community amenities like green roofs, safe parking, swimming pool, sundeck and fully equipped fitness center. Conveniently located near art, music, shopping and restaurant venues.
Verified
40 Units Available
The Brio
410 W Princeton Ave
Yaphank, NY | Yaphank
1 Bedroom
$2,395
768 sqft
2 Bedrooms
$2,700
1066 sqft
3 Bedrooms
$3,450
1436 sqft
Last updated April 21 at 9:25 AM
Nestled in Yaphank at the heart of Long Island, The Brio brings new style and spirit to the comfort and convenience of the suburbs. Your lifestyle here comes with more space in carriage homes, mid-rise and townhome apartments. Here, you can work out in the on-site fitness center, plugin with co-working space in the resident lounge, and run with your furry friend in our fenced Bark Park. This is the combination of neighborhood warmth and stylish luxury. This is living your Brio.
Verified
88 Units Available
The Wel
75 E. Hoffman Avenue
Lindenhurst, NY | Lindenhurst
Studio
$2,675
723 sqft
1 Bedroom
$2,515
749 sqft
2 Bedrooms
$3,080
1117 sqft
Last updated April 21 at 9:25 AM
No matter where the day takes you, home is the ultimate destination. Located in the charming Village of Lindenhurst, NY, The Wel has been thoughtfully appointed with expansive community amenities and in-unit features, so it’s a place you’ll love coming home to. With a pool and rooftop patio deck, a 24-hour fitness center, cozy fire pits, bike storage, a dog wash station and so much more, you actually may never want to leave. Pure comfort and convenience coverage at The Wel.
Verified
12 Units Available
Rosemont Brookhaven
1220 Orchid Cir
Bellport, NY | North Bellport
1 Bedroom
$2,330
968 sqft
2 Bedrooms
$2,337
1199 sqft
3 Bedrooms
$2,630
1267 sqft
Last updated April 21 at 6:25 AM
Community has a tennis court, gym, car wash area, and games room. Units are recently renovated with granite counters and in-unit laundry. Extra storage. Quiet setting near Sills Road shopping. Access to Sunrise Hwy and I-495.
Verified
8 Units Available
Southpoint
25 Weaver Dr
East Massapequa, NY | East Massapequa
Studio
Ask
1 Bedroom
$2,399
704 sqft
2 Bedrooms
$3,150
1191 sqft
Last updated April 21 at 6:22 AM
Close to Highway 27A and Merrick Road. Extensive community includes a pool, a sauna, a courtyard, a community garden, a 24-hour gym and a clubhouse with coffee bar. Stainless steel appliances and fireplace included.
1 Unit Available
55 Rose Lane
55 Rose Lane
Gordon Heights, NY | Gordon Heights
4 Bedrooms
$2,925
1400 sqft
Last updated April 21 at 8:44 AM
NOW AVAILABLE! Exclusively listed by Hudson Homes Management. Hurry, this home will not last long! Apply TODAY! Featuring 4 bedrooms, 2 baths, this Hudson home includes attached garage, open kitchen, spacious yard, and much more! Schedule your convenient self-tour today! For FAQ's, visit https://www.hudsonhomesmanagement.com/faqs.aspx Prospective tenants to verify all information within this listing including, but not limited to, Bedrooms, Bathrooms, and Square Footage. Avoid Rental Scams: Hudson Homes Management does not advertise on Craigslist and will never ask you to wire money or request funds through a payment app on your mobile device. CONSENT TO TEXT MESSAGING: By entering your mobile phone number, you expressly consent to receive text messages from Hudson Homes Management. Msg & Data rates may apply. This property allows self guided viewing without an appointment. Contact for details.
1 Unit Available
23 Bishop Avenue
23 Bishop Avenue
Westhampton, NY | Westhampton
4 Bedrooms
$60,000
Last updated April 21 at 8:15 AM
Spend August in this thoughtfully designed renovated home. Open concept floor plan - light & airy with meticulous attention to detail. Gourmet kitchen, dining area & living room with fireplace all opens to a spacious deck overlooking golf course. Heated gunite pool, 2 car garage and close to local shops & restaurants. Tenant responsible for beach access. Plan summer 2021 now!!
1 Unit Available
1 Woodedge Trail
1 Woodedge Trail
Quogue, NY | Quogue
4 Bedrooms
$7,800
2600 sqft
Last updated April 21 at 8:15 AM
2.5 acre estate setting. UV air filtration. Energy efficient pool heating. All new rugs, upholstered furniture, and bedding. Indoor/outdoor sound system, magnificent landscaping. Two-car garage.
1 Unit Available
168 Alicia Drive
168 Alicia Drive
North Babylon, NY | North Babylon
2 Bedrooms
$3,000
1400 sqft
Last updated April 21 at 8:15 AM
Desirable 2 Bedroom 2.5 Bath Townhome In Gated Community Of Woods Edge. Living Room With Cathedral Ceilings, Fireplace, Sliders to Deck, CAC, Garage, Basement .Laundry. No Smoking, No Pets.
1 Unit Available
19 Woodland Way
19 Woodland Way
Quogue, NY | Quogue
4 Bedrooms
$30,000
2800 sqft
Last updated April 21 at 8:15 AM
Quogue - Spacious Multi Level Contemporary Home Picturesque Lot. Entry Foyer To The Media Room With Remote Blinds And Projection Player, Main Living Area Offers Living Room W/Fireplace, Dining Area (Both With Sliders To Deck), Euro Kitchen, Laundry Room And Powder Room, Down 1/2 Level To Guest Bedroom, Bath Plus Game/Exercise Room, Up To Master Bedroom Suite And Up 1/2 Level From There To 2 Bdrms And Bath Plus A Loft With Fireplace. Heated Pool, Hot Tub, Outdoor Shower & Sport Court, Garage.
Find More Rentals By

Bedrooms

Fire Island 2 Bedroom Apartments
Find More Rentals in Nearby
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Frequently Asked Questions
How much is rent for an apartment with a garage in Fire Island?
Rental prices for apartments with garages in Fire Island range from $6,000 to $35,000 per month.
How many apartments with garages are available for rent in Fire Island?
Currently, there are 4 apartments with garages available for rent in Fire Island.
What to keep in mind when looking for apartments with garages in Fire Island, NY

Fire Island apartments with garages are sometimes more expensive than other options. However, they may make more financial sense in the long run.

Weather, break-ins, and daily struggles to find a space can take a toll financially and physically. Remember that even cities in mild climates experience issues like salt air, tornadoes, hail, falling branches from storms, and other issues.

It’s also possible to score an auto insurance reduction if you park in a garage. Ask your insurance provider about any deals or discounts that could trim money off the cost of your monthly bill.

Before signing a lease, ask the landlord or property manager about any restrictions on garage use. It’s important to know if there are enough spaces for tenants and visitors and what happens if the garage is full. If you’re moving into an apartment inside a home, ask about any conditions on its use and if storage is allowed.