What Are the Safest Columbus Neighborhoods for Renters in 2025? (Crime & Rent Data)

Columbus offers plenty of safe neighborhoods for renters in 2025, and this guide highlights five of the best, including Harrison West, Victorian Village, and Tuttle West. With safety being a key concern for many, it’s crucial to know where crime rates are decreasing, rents remain affordable, and everyday living feels secure.

From calm suburbs to vibrant urban areas, these are the safest neighborhoods in Columbus, according to 2025 crime rate data. Below, you’ll find a detailed overview of each area, including rent costs, safety scores, and daily life.

Is Columbus Safe for Renters?

Columbus is becoming safer for renters in 2025. The city has seen a significant drop in homicides during the first few months of 2025, the lowest number reported in 15 years. As of April 28, there have been 16 homicides, according to the report from the Columbus Division of Police. Felonious assaults have also declined substantially. There were 230 reported incidents as of April 28, down from 293 in 2024 and 437 in 2023.

The city currently holds a C- crime grade, ranked in the 33rd percentile, which means it’s safer than about one in three U.S. cities.

CrimeGrade data finds that the Columbus area is as safe as the Ohio state average. Further improvements are expected, thanks to recent efforts by the Columbus Division of Police. Increased community collaboration has led to more resident tips than ever before, strengthening law enforcement’s ability to address crime.

However, citywide statistics can sometimes mask important differences between neighborhoods. That’s why renters pay attention to neighborhood-level safety data when choosing the safest places to live in Columbus.

Columbus Crime Trends in 2025

• Columbus saw a historic drop in homicides in early 2025, with only 16 total reported.
• Felonious assaults are down in 2025 compared to 2024, with 63 fewer incidents reported across the city.
• The cost of crime per resident in Columbus is around $412 per year, $52 less than the national average.
• Forecasts from Columbus Mayor Andrew Ginther suggest ongoing declines in crime through 2025, fueled by targeted efforts to reduce non-fatal shootings and investments in better street lighting and security camera coverage.

Crime Index: A composite score (0–100) indicating how a city’s total crime compares to the national average; lower scores = safer.

These trends suggest that while Columbus faces elevated crime challenges, the downward trajectory, especially in violent and property offenses, reflects effective policing initiatives and community partnerships.

Violent vs. Property Crime Breakdown

Theft drives most of the overall crime increase, accounting for over 10.6 incidents per 1,000 people.

How Safer Neighborhoods Compare to Citywide Averages

Renters in Columbus who value safety will find reassurance in nearby neighborhoods where crime rates regularly fall below the citywide averages for both violent and property crimes.

Tuttle West has a crime rate of 18.16 per 1,000 residents, compared to Columbus’ 30.23, making it a noticeably safer choice. Residents benefit from well-lit streets and active neighborhood programs, along with a shorter commute and moderate rent prices.

East Broad boasts a crime rate of 24.90 per 1,000 residents, which makes it safer than the state and national average. Safety features like improved street lighting and a strong police presence, contribute to the neighborhood’s appeal—particularly for renters seeking affordability without compromising on security.

How We Identified Columbus’ Safest Neighborhoods

To identify the safest neighborhoods for renters in Columbus in 2025, we reviewed the latest crime data alongside local rental rates and population trends. Our approach focused on delivering precise, up-to-date insights tailored specifically for renters.

We compared violent and property crime rates in each neighborhood against citywide and national benchmarks, emphasizing crime rates per capita rather than just total incidents to provide a full picture of everyday safety. We then paired this information with 2025 rent figures to spotlight neighborhoods that combine security with affordability.

We also factored in walkability scores, school quality, and proximity to key amenities to capture important lifestyle factors for renters. Whether you’re moving alone or with family, this list highlights Columbus neighborhoods that offer both safety and a great quality of life—based on real data, not assumptions.

Data Sources and Time Frames

Our rankings are built from a multi-source dataset covering the most recent crime and rent trends in Columbus:

• Columbus Division of Police (April 2025 – Present)
• Apartment List Rent Estimates (Q2 2025, >8,000 active listings)
• Apartments.com

Ranking Factors (Crime Rate, Rent, Amenities, Commute)

Each neighborhood was evaluated with the following factor weightings:

Factor Weights

• Crime Rate (50%) – Based on combined violent and property crime per 1,000 residents; lower rates score higher.

• Rent Affordability (20%) – Median 1‑bedroom rent compared to city median ($1,445); neighborhoods below median score better.

• Amenities (20%) – Composite metric including: \

  • Parks per square mile (scored 0–10)
  • Walk Score (0–100)
  • Grocery stores within 1 mile (0–5) \

• Commute (10%) – Average peak-hour drive time to Downtown Columbus; shorter commutes yield higher scores.

Each neighborhood on this list received the best scores compared to the overall neighborhoods in Columbus.

Crime-to-Rent Ratio Explained

Crime-to-Rent Ratio: the number of reported crimes per $1,000 of median annual rent. A lower ratio means you're getting more safety for every dollar you spend on housing.

For example, if a neighborhood reports 200 crimes per year and the median rent is $1,200/month ($14,400/year), the crime-to-rent ratio would be 13.9 crimes per $1,000 of rent.

This metric is especially helpful for cost-conscious renters. Instead of just chasing the lowest price or safest ZIP code, the ratio lets you weigh both factors together, showing which neighborhoods offer the best value in terms of both affordability and peace of mind.

5 Safest Columbus Neighborhoods for Renters

Looking for a secure place to call home in Columbus? These nine neighborhoods offer the best mix of low crime rates, renter-friendly pricing, and community-driven lifestyles, backed by comprehensive 2025 data on violent and property crime, rent prices, and safety initiatives.

Harrison West – Modern Convenience

• Violent Crime: 2.184/1,000
• Property Crime: 14.74/1,000
• Average One-Bedroom Rent: $1,629
• Crime-to-Rent Ratio: 0.11

Harrison West blends historic character with modern urban living in Columbus, offering quick access to the Short North Arts District, cafés, and scenic trails.

With violent crime occurring at just 2.184 per 1,000 residents, Harrison West serves as one of Columbus’ safer central neighborhoods. The area benefits from an active civic association, enhanced street lighting, and regular community patrols. Many residential buildings are also equipped with advanced security systems and gated parking. Residents enjoy a calm, walkable community with a 5–10 minute commute to Downtown Columbus.

Victorian Village – Classic, Walkable

• Violent Crime: 2.407/1,000
• Property Crime: 21.03/1,000
• Average One-Bedroom Rent: $1,287
• Crime-to-Rent Ratio: 0.15

Victorian Village offers a classic feel with convenient walkability. Filled with leafy streets, the neighborhood is conveniently close to Goodale Park, High Street restaurants.

With violent crime rates at 2.407 per 1,000 residents, the neighborhood continues to see safety improvements. Victorian Village features active neighborhood associations and well-lit streets. Its central location also allows for a quick commute to Downtown Columbus.

Italian Village – Historic, Young Professional-Friendly

• Violent Crime: 5.534/1,000
• Property Crime: 22.87/1,000
• Average One-Bedroom Rent: $1,392
• Crime-to-Rent Ratio: 0.33

Italian Village combines historic charm with trendy vibes. Known for its chic lofts and busy coffee shops, the area offers walkability to various shops and breweries. There is also convenient proximity to several COTA bus lines.

Violent crime rates are currently 5.534 per 1,000 residents, and recent efforts aim to drive continuous improvements. These include new mixed-use developments and upgraded lighting through residential streets. Offering about a 10 minute commute to Downtown Columbus, it’s a popular pick for young professionals.

Tuttle West – Safe and Versatile

• Violent Crime: 1.476/1,000
• Property Crime: 8.327/1,000
• Average One-Bedroom Rent: $1,345
• Crime-to-Rent Ratio: 0.09

Tuttle West blends suburban vibes with modern appeal. Known for its newer buildings and quick access to the Mall at Tuttle Crossing, it’s a good fit for both families and professionals.

With a crime rate of just 1.476 per 1,000 residents, Tuttle West is significantly safer than many other neighborhoods in Columbus. Many properties have gated access and smart home features, and responsive local patrols further contribute to its safety profile. Residents enjoy a 12–15 minute commute to Downtown Columbus.

East Broad – Growing, Family-oriented

• Violent Crime: 1.682/1000
• Property Crime: 11.27/1,000
• Average One-Bedroom Rent: $1,058
• Crime-to-Rent Ratio: 0.13

Known for its wide streets, East Broad offers quick access to several local schools and bus routes. It’s a solid choice for renters looking for space and value without getting too far away from the city.

East Broad has a crime rate of just 1.682 per 1,000 residents, and new safety investments are helping improve it even further. Upgrades include better street lighting, a stronger patrol presence, and active engagement from organizations aiming to reduce property crime. Renters enjoy a quick 10–12 minute commute to Downtown Columbus.

Neighborhood Comparison: Crime, Rent, Commute at a Glance

Average Rent Differences Across Ranked Neighborhoods

Among the safest Columbus neighborhoods, rent is generally comparable, with East Broad and Victorian Village having the lower rents.

Still, higher rent doesn’t always mean lower crime. However, areas like Harrison West and Italian Village may be more likely to have gated communities or higher security protocols in place.

Average Commute Time to Downtown, Santa Monica, Burbank Studios

We calculated Columbus commute times (2025) from each ranked neighborhood to three major job hubs. Car times reflect typical weekday traffic (8–9:30am), and Metro estimates use official route data.

From Harrison West

• Downtown Columbus (via OH-315 S and W Broad St) – 10 minutes
• Downtown Columbus (via public transit) – 15 minutes
• University District (via Neil Ave and W Lane Ave) – 5 minutes
• Logistics & E‑Commerce Corridor (via US-23 S and Alum Creek Dr) – 15 minutes

From Victorian Village

• Downtown Columbus (via Neil Ave and W Broad St) – 8 minutes
• Downtown Columbus (via public transit) – 12 minutes
• University District (via Neil Ave and W Lane Ave) – 6 minutes
• Logistics & E‑Commerce Corridor (via US-23 S and Alum Creek Dr) – 18 minutes

From Italian Village

• Downtown Columbus (via N 4th St and E Broad St) – 6 minutes
• Downtown Columbus (via public transit) – 10 minutes
• University District (via Summit St and E Lane Ave) – 8 minutes
• Logistics & E‑Commerce Corridor (via I-670 E and Alum Creek Dr) – 20 minutes

From Tuttle West

• Downtown Columbus (via I‑270 S and I‑70 E) – 20 minutes
• Downtown Columbus (via public transit) – 30 minutes
• University District (via I‑270 S and OH‑315 S) – 15 minutes
• Logistics & E‑Commerce Corridor (via I‑270 S and Alum Creek Dr) – 25 minutes

From East Broad

• Downtown Columbus (via E Broad St) – 10 minutes
• Downtown Columbus (via public transit) – 15 minutes
• University District (via E Broad St and N High St) – 15 minutes
• Logistics & E‑Commerce Corridor (via I‑70 E and Alum Creek Dr) – 25 minutes

Choosing the Right Safe Neighborhood for Your Lifestyle

Safety isn’t one-size-fits-all. Some renters seek a peaceful suburban vibe, while others want walkability or proximity to public transit. Here’s how to find the right balance.

Transit-friendly yet safe areas if you don’t own a car

If you're car-free but still want peace of mind, these neighborhoods offer strong safety scores and public transit access:

• Italian Village – Walk Score: 90 \ Key Routes: COTA Routes 2, 3, and 10; nearby access to CMAX Bus Rapid Transit along Cleveland Avenue
• Victorian Village – Walk Score: 88 \ Key Routes: COTA Routes 2 and 10; easy access to High Street corridor transit
• Harrison West** **– Walk Score: 75 \ Key Routes: COTA Routes 2 and 10; close to downtown circulator and Short North transit options

Up-and-coming affordable pockets to watch

You don’t have to choose an expensive area to feel secure. Several rising neighborhoods are making strides in safety while still providing affordable rent options:

• East Broad: A good choice for budget-conscious renters seeking safer neighborhoods without sacrificing affordability.
• Tuttle West: Known for solid safety gains, moderate rent, and a shorter commute, making it popular among working professionals.
• Victorian Village: Offers reasonable rents, ongoing safety improvements, and convenient proximity to downtown Columbus.

Key indicators include:

• New mixed-use developments
• Consistent decline in crime rates
• Enhanced lighting and upgraded surveillance systems

Check block-level safety before signing a lease

Not all streets are the same. Even in “safe” neighborhoods, your specific location makes a difference. Here’s how to research a block before you commit:

1. Pull the address up on the Ohio Office of Criminal Justice Services crime map
2. Check community safety apps like Citizen or Nextdoor for recent incidents
3. Visit the area after dark to observe streetlights, foot traffic, and the overall atmosphere
4. Ask the landlord about security features—many now include smart home tech perks like video doorbells, smart locks, and motion-activated lighting

Doing this research ahead of time helps you avoid surprises and feel confident about your new home.

How Apartment List’s Quiz Matches You Faster

Apartment List has a quick AI-driven quiz that takes under 90 seconds to complete. It assesses your priorities to deliver customized apartment options tailored to your lifestyle, helping you find the right place faster and smarter.

Take the quiz today to find your best matches..

Frequently Asked Questions About Columbus’ Safest Neighborhoods

Which safe Columbus neighborhoods offer the lowest average rent?

East Broad and Victorian Village come out on top for affordability and safety, with one-bedroom rents under $1,300 and violent-crime rates below the Columbus average.

Are there safe areas in Columbus?

Yes, Tuttle West and East Broad have violent-crime rates below 2.0 per 1,000, far lower than the citywide average.

How current is the crime Data in this guide?

All crime data is based on reports from April 2025 to present, sourced from the Columbus Division of Police.

What online tools help monitor neighborhood safety?

Ohio’s Office of Criminal Justice Services crime map and platforms like SpotCrime and NeighborhoodScout allow residents to track incidents in real time, ideal for evaluating areas before touring.