Get our mobile app

Search apartments on the go

Company

About us
Careers
Company news
Product updates
Sunny.com (opens in new tab)
Support (opens in new tab)
FAQ (opens in new tab)
Sitemap

For renters

Renter Hub
Rate My Rent
Cost of Living Calculator
Rent Calculator
Renter Life blog
Rent Report

For property owners

A-List Portal (opens in new tab)
A-List Smart Platform (opens in new tab)
A-List Market (opens in new tab)
A-List Nurture (opens in new tab)
A-List Resident (opens in new tab)
Rental Management blog
Rental Data & Insights blog
Help Center (opens in new tab)

Privacy & policies

Privacy policy
Terms of use
Accessibility (opens in new tab)
Do not sell or share my info

(opens in new tab) (opens in new tab) (opens in new tab) (opens in new tab) (opens in new tab) (opens in new tab) (opens in new tab)

© 2026 Apartment List, Inc. All rights reserved.

Home Search Short list

List with us (opens in new tab)

Home Search Short list

List with us (opens in new tab)

Modern apartment interior

Get matched with your perfect apartment—faster

Smarter moves, less stress

Renter HubMoving, insurance, payments, and more
Rate My RentIs your rent a good deal?
Cost of Living CalculatorCalculate your city's cost of living
Rent CalculatorFind your rent sweet spot
Renter Life blogNavigating life as a renter
Rent ReportFind the best time to move

For property owners

A-List Portal (opens in new tab)
A-List Smart Platform (opens in new tab)
A-List Market (opens in new tab)
A-List Nurture (opens in new tab)
A-List Resident (opens in new tab)
Rental Management blog
Rental Data & Insights blog
Help Center (opens in new tab)

Home
Search
Short list

Start your Monticello, NY search

How many bedrooms do you need?

Home/
NY/
Sullivan County/
Monticello Apartments

Apartments for Rent in Monticello, NY

6 rentals available

Start your Monticello search

How many bedrooms do you need?

Top cities

Middletown Apartments
Newburgh Apartments
Newton Apartments
Hopatcong Apartments
Lake Mohawk Apartments
Scotchtown Apartments
Saw Creek Apartments
Port Jervis Apartments
Warwick Apartments
Woodbury Apartments

Average rent in Monticello, New York

The average rent for a 1 bedroom apartment in Monticello is $1,350+, while the average rent for a 2 bedroom apartment is Ask. Rent rates updated 4 days ago

Studio: $775+
Prices trending down
1 Bed: $1,350+
Prices trending down
2 Beds: Ask
Prices trending down
3+ Beds: Ask
Prices trending down

* Averages are based on the rental prices of properties listed on Apartment List that don’t include fees

20 Best Apartments In Monticello, NY (with verified reviews)!

Listings

26 Lakewood Avenue Gallery 1

1 of 10

26 Lakewood Avenue (opens in new tab)

26 Lakewood Avenue, Monticello, NY 12701

$2,600/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

5 bed

42 Bennett Street Gallery 1

1 of 9

15 Kinch Lane Gallery 1

1 of 10

70 High Street Gallery 1

1 of 7

422 Broadway Gallery 1

1 of 9

420 Broadway Gallery 1

1 of 5

Amenities

Patio / balcony, Recently renovated, Courtyard, Range, Oven, and Refrigerator

42 Bennett Street (opens in new tab)

42 Bennett Street, Monticello, NY 12701

$1,800/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

3 bed

Amenities

Parking, Recently renovated, and Oven

15 Kinch Lane (opens in new tab)

15 Kinch Lane, Monticello, NY 12701

$2,200/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

4 bed

Amenities

Patio / balcony, Parking, Recently renovated, Range, Oven, and Refrigerator

70 High Street (opens in new tab)

70 High Street, Monticello, NY 12701

$775/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

Studio

Amenities

Parking, Range, and Refrigerator

422 Broadway (opens in new tab)

422 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701

$1,350/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

1 bed

Amenities

Cats allowed, Parking, Recently renovated, Oven, and Refrigerator

420 Broadway (opens in new tab)

420 Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701

$1,350/moFees may apply12-mo lease

1 unit available

1 bed

Amenities

Cats allowed, Parking, Recently renovated, Oven, and Refrigerator

Find more rentals by

Colleges

Sussex County Community College (33)
Orange County Community College (23)

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Best market deals

These units are the best deal in town.

70 High Street 5

Studio • 1 Bath • 500 sqft

Base monthly rent

$775+

Available

Now

422 Broadway 5

1 Bed • 2 Baths • 800 sqft

Base monthly rent

$1,350+

Available

Now

420 Broadway 3

1 Bed • 1 Bath • 650 sqft

Base monthly rent

$1,350+

Available

Now

42 Bennett Street 3 Bed

3 Beds • 1 Bath • 785 sqft

Base monthly rent

$1,800+

Available

Now

15 Kinch Lane 4 Bed

4 Beds • 1 Bath • 1386 sqft

Base monthly rent

$2,200+

Available

Now