Start your Bay Shore search
How many bedrooms do you need?

Apartments for Rent in Bay Shore, NY

16 rentals available
  • 5.0

    Shoregate

    143 4th Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (631) 892-2861
    $2,412+ moTotal price12-mo lease

    Top rated for Location
    Most days I can find parking but some nights I’m not so lucky. And my hallway is a busy hallway so I tend to hear the dogs barking BUT it’s not an every day thing so it’s fine!
    18 units available
    Studio • 1 bed • 2 bed • 3 bed
    Amenities

    In unit laundry, Golf room, Patio / balcony, Hardwood floors, Dishwasher, Gym + more

    Verified listing
    Verified
  • Fairfield North At Bay Shore

    $1,900
    25 South Clinton Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (631) 572-8155

    1 unit available
    1 bed
    Amenities

    Cats allowed, Parking, and Some paid utils

  • 1603 Union Boulevard

    $2,500
    1603 Union Boulevard, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (631) 678-8308

    1 unit available
    2 bed
    Amenities

    Parking, Internet access, Range, Oven, and Refrigerator

  • 34 Colorado Avenue

    $2,250
    34 Colorado Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (516) 761-2399

    1 unit available
    1 bed
    Amenities

    All utils included and Refrigerator

  • Bay Shore city guide
    Everything you need to know
  • Featured Unit 1
    Best market deals
    These units are the best deal in town.
  • 41 Chapman Place

    $3,100
    41 Chapman Place, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (516) 761-2399

    1 unit available
    1 bed
    Amenities

    Parking and Stainless steel

  • 103 3rd Avenue

    $3,500
    103 Third Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (631) 417-2575

    1 unit available
    3 bed
    Amenities

    Granite counters, Parking, and Recently renovated

  • 24 Poplar Pl

    $2,300
    24 Poplar Place, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (516) 960-6456

    1 unit available
    1 bed
    Amenities

    In unit laundry, Pet friendly, Garage, and Recently renovated

  • 227 4th Avenue unit: 211J

    $2,950
    227 4th Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (516) 978-1969

    1 unit available
    1 bed
    Amenities

    In unit laundry, Granite counters, Pet friendly, Parking, Stainless steel, and Elevator

  • 12 Maple Court

    $4,800
    12 Maple Court, Bay Shore, NY 11706

    1 unit available
    5 bed
    Amenities

    Dishwasher, Parking, Fireplace, and Oven

  • 72 Tudor Lane

    $2,600
    72 Tudor Lane, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (516) 359-9281

    1 unit available
    2 bed
    Amenities

    In unit laundry, Patio / balcony, Granite counters, Dishwasher, Parking, Recently renovated + more

  • Featured Unit 1
    Luxury apartments
    Top units for an elevated lifestyle.
  • 20-22 Bay Shore Avenue

    $4,000
    20 Bay Shore Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (866) 664-0347

    1 unit available
    4 bed
    Amenities

    Parking, Fireplace, and Range

  • 39 Redmond Avenue

    $4,200
    39 Redmond Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (516) 799-1900

    1 unit available
    4 bed
    Amenities

    In unit laundry, Hardwood floors, Garage, Recently renovated, Bbq/grill, and Microwave

  • 58 S Clinton Avenue

    $2,400
    58 South Clinton Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (516) 714-3606

    1 unit available
    1 bed
    Amenities

    In unit laundry, Walk in closets, Extra storage, and Refrigerator

  • 85 Newbrook Lane

    $2,300
    85 Newbrook Lane, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (631) 665-1500

    1 unit available
    1 bed
    Amenities

    In unit laundry, Parking, Internet access, and Refrigerator

  • 21 Rhodes Avenue

    $4,300
    21 Rhodes Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (631) 351-6000

    1 unit available
    4 bed
    Amenities

    Garage

  • 175 Newbrook Lane

    $2,300
    175 Newbrook Lane, Bay Shore, NY 11706
    (631) 665-1500

    1 unit available
    1 bed
    Amenities

    In unit laundry, Parking, Internet access, and Refrigerator

Average rent in Bay Shore, New York

City Guide
The average rent for a 1 bedroom apartment in Bay Shore is $3,232+, while the average rent for a 2 bedroom apartment is $4,595+. Rent rates updated ago
Studio
$2,445+Trending up
1 Bed
$3,232+Trending up
2 Beds
$4,595+Trending up
3+ Beds
$5,527+Trending up
* Averages are based on the rental prices of properties listed on Apartment List that don’t include fees

More Rental Options

Find an apartment for rent in Bay Shore, NY

Searching for an apartment for rent in Bay Shore, NY? Look no further! Apartment List will help you find a perfect apartment near you. There are 16 available rental units listed on Apartment List in Bay Shore. Click on listings to see photos, floorplans, amenities, prices and availability, and much more!

The average rent in Bay Shore is $2,445 for a studio, $3,232 for a one-bedroom apartment, and $4,595 for a two-bedroom apartment. If you are looking for a deal, keep an eye out for a red pulsing icon that indicates rent specials.

Tired of browsing? Take our personalized quiz. You’ll answer a couple of simple questions and we’ll put together a list of Bay Shore apartments that are best for you. We’ll also factor in your commute, budget, and preferred amenities. Looking for a pet-friendly rental, or an apartment with in-unit washer and dryer? No problem, we’ll provide you with apartments that match that criteria.

You can trust Apartment List to help you find your next Bay Shore, NY apartment rental! After all, everyone deserves a home they love.

Frequently Asked Questions

Living in Bay Shore, NY

Leave the racket of New York City behind and head out to Bay Shore, a city filled with white sand beaches that has served as home to LL Cool J and former San Francisco politician Harvey Milk.

Bay Shore’s history can be traced back to its founding in 1697

View Bay Shore City Guide
Sources:
  • School data: GreatSchools
  • Crime data: CrimeIndex (U.S.) provided by Precisely used data sourced from Precisely, the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), and various law enforcement agencies. These organizations do not accept responsibility for the accuracy or completeness of the data used in this product.