11 photos
    The Point at Sutton Hill
    2 Underhill Road, Middletown
    • 1 Bedroom
      $1,305
      +
    • 2 Bedrooms
      $1,535
      +
    • 3 Bedrooms
      $1,820
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    29 photos
    East Coast Imperial Gardens LLC
    225 Berkman Dr, Middletown
    • 1 Bedroom
      $1,015
      +
    • 2 Bedrooms
      $1,105
      +
    • 3 Bedrooms
      $1,615
      +
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    23 photos
    Crestwood Apts
    92 Fitzgerald Dr, Middletown
    • Studio
      $807
    • 1 Bedroom
      $979
      +
    • 2 Bedrooms
      $1,087
      +
    • 3 Bedrooms
      $1,274
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    9 photos
    The Regency Club
    1200 Regency Court, Middletown
    • 1 Bedroom
      $1,325
      +
    • 2 Bedrooms
      $1,475
      +
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    16 photos
    525 Silver Lake Scotchtown Road
    525 Silver Lake Scotchtown Road, Middletown
    • 4 Bedrooms
      $2,300
    (845) 928-8000
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    11 photos
    23 West Main Street
    23 West Main Street, Middletown
    • 1 Bedroom
      $1,075
    (845) 649-5614
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    2 photos
    2442 Goshen Turnpike
    2442 Goshen Turnpike, Middletown
    • 2 Bedrooms
      $1,500
    (845) 928-8000
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    5 photos
    45 Lexington Way
    45 Lexington Way, Middletown
    • 3 Bedrooms
      $1,850
    (917) 553-6262
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    11 photos
    42 Poplar Lane
    42 Poplar Lane, Middletown
    • 3 Bedrooms
      $1,750
    (845) 807-9794
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    1 photo
    20 Silo
    20 Silo, Middletown
    • 3 Bedrooms
      $1,450
    (845) 928-8000
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    14 photos
    2444 Goshen Turnpike
    2444 Goshen Turnpike, Middletown
    • 2 Bedrooms
      $1,500
    (845) 928-8000
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    15 photos
    29 Van Dewark Road
    29 Van Dewark Road, Middletown
    • 4 Bedrooms
      $2,800
    (845) 457-9174
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    13 photos
    117 Ruth Court
    117 Ruth Court, Middletown
    • 2 Bedrooms
      $1,300
    (845) 928-8000
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    20 photos
    1 Cherry Street
    1 Cherry Street, Middletown
    • 3 Bedrooms
      $1,600
    (845) 988-5000
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    1 photo
    100 Excelsior Avenue
    100 Excelsior Avenue, Middletown
    • 3 Bedrooms
      $1,700
    (845) 202-0773
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    14 photos
    630 Van Burenville Road
    630 Van Burenville Road, Middletown
    • 3 Bedrooms
      $2,000
    (845) 341-3472
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    5 photos
    67 Poplar
    67 Poplar, Middletown
    • 2 Bedrooms
      $1,100
    (917) 553-6262
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    23 photos
    155 Deer Ct Drive
    155 Deer Ct Drive, Middletown
    • 2 Bedrooms
      $1,550
    (845) 344-2800
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    4 photos
    100 Hillside Drive
    100 Hillside Drive, Middletown
    • 1 Bedroom
      $1,300
    (845) 294-9333
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
    12 photos
    100 Hillside Drive
    100 Hillside Drive, Middletown
    • 2 Bedrooms
      $1,200
    (845) 928-8000
    Check Availability
    Photo & Details
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. Next

Middletown is also located in the Hudson Valley about 75-miles north of New York City. Though the commute time is frequently over an hour and a half, the Metro-North Port Jervis Line, with a stop in neighboring Wallkill, can make the ride more pleasant.

Many Middletown neighborhoods are located outside the city’s urban areas. Whether it’s to the east towards Goshen, the north towards Scotchtown, or the south towards New Hampton, new development in the suburban areas of Middletown remain the best option for housing. Due to the variety of apartment rentals—including townhomes and condominiums—you should be able to find a great place in this region, even if you’re looking for a short-term lease or a studio apartment for rent. The Presidential Heights neighborhood in particular has a number of desirable apartment rentals, frequently with amenities including gyms, pools and clubhouses. Two bedrooms in these regions generally range from $1100 to $1300.

Throughout the rest of Middletown, there are a number of cheap apartments, particularly around Highland Avenue and in Mechanicstown. You can occasionally find old, historic rental homes here, as well. Two bedrooms here range from $900 to $1100.

So welcome to Middletown! Once you’ve found a neighborhood for you, it’s pretty sweet here.

About Apartment List

Apartment List is your go-to rental site for your apartment search. Browse thousands of new listings every day to give you the largest selection of cheap 1 bedroom, 2 bedroom and 3 bedroom apartments for rent in Middletown. Find studios, condos, townhomes, and homes in your favorite neighborhoods. You can search for all utilities paid apartments, and pet-friendly homes with the tap of a button. With more available listings than Craigslist, you're sure to find a house for rent on Apartment List.

Loading icon
Click where you want to live—
The map will zoom.
Feedback